Churchill Knight & Boox clients being investigated as Managed Service Companies

[DealorNoDeal]

...I understand the initial appeals are being stood over, without really being looked at in detail by HMRC.

Almost certainly this.

The only thing that matters is to get your appeal in within the time limit (30 days?), and include the required wording. I think it needs to say something about requesting postponement of payment as well as that you want to appeal. That's why it's not a bad idea to use a proven template.

Also, send it recorded delivery.

[Guy Incognito]

Just got my 2018/19 and 2019/20 determinations in the post, dated 23 November 2022!

[GregRickshaw]

Just got my 2018/19 and 2019/20 determinations in the post, dated 23 November 2022!

Oh no that's bad.

So you have technically missed your deadline to appeal, whilst it's a worrying turn there are several on here who seem to have had theirs issued/dated about 9 months ago (and only just received) and AFAIK not had to pay up

HRMC surely can't blame the posties for this?

[raiden430]

First time posting here with nothing useful to contribute other than just vent and sit in self-pity.
Just added up how much CT and DT I payed for the 3 years in question and it totalled to £119K (If I include S455 Tax) and £97K if I don't include it.

HMRC is asking me to cough up £100K.

What are the chances that they could calculate it properly and I could just pay them 3k and be done with it lol.

[Chevalier]

First time posting here with nothing useful to contribute other than just vent and sit in self-pity.
Just added up how much CT and DT I payed for the 3 years in question and it totalled to £119K (If I include S455 Tax) and £97K if I don't include it.

HMRC is asking me to cough up £100K.

What are the chances that they could calculate it properly and I could just pay them 3k and be done with it lol.

Have you factored in NI claims?

[raiden430]

Have you factored in NI claims?

The latest letter I received from HMRC includes Tax + Class 1 NIC for the 3 years + Interest.

It's a total joke. They're asking for 100K when I've already paid 119K?

[GregRickshaw]

The latest letter I received from HMRC includes Tax + Class 1 NIC for the 3 years + Interest.

It's a total joke. They're asking for 100K when I've already paid 119K?

Plus interest? Can you expand on this please? I think it's the first time we have seen an interest amount actually calculated.

As to your other point if you have paid your CT and DT then you should.... should get that back... HMRC are still edgy on this.
So the liability if they win will be your Employers NIC * the number of years, very roughly.

[GregRickshaw]

First time posting here with nothing useful to contribute other than just vent and sit in self-pity.
Just added up how much CT and DT I payed for the 3 years in question and it totalled to £119K (If I include S455 Tax) and £97K if I don't include it.

HMRC is asking me to cough up £100K.

What are the chances that they could calculate it properly and I could just pay them 3k and be done with it lol.

I think many of us based just on the determination letters had our bills reduced to nothing or even negative.

They then hit you with NIC

[raiden430]

I can give an example. This is part of the letter

[GregRickshaw]

Wow so that's either 11% interest on the whole lot
or
20%! on the determinations.

Where the hell do they get that rate from and that is utterly outrageous.