BN66 - JR Judgement Day

[Douglas]

Come on...someone help us with an update please...!!

Please god dont tell us we have been robbed...????

Confirmed. The judgement went against us.

[malvolio]

Truly sorry to hear that, everyone. Must be a huge disappointment.

[swede]

i feel sick.

[NickFitz]

Really sorry everybody

[patbikeruk]

Please tell me this is a joke........

[Lazylobster]

Well, we need to hear / understand the judgement.

The battle may be lost, but the war is not over. . .

fight on !

LL

[chef]

Just got back from the court room. The judge sat down, said straight out "I dismiss the case for judicial review".

Judicial Review

What is judicial review?

2.1 Judicial review is the procedure by which you can seek to challenge the decision, action or failure to act of a public body such as a government department or a local authority or other body exercising a public law function. If you are challenging the decision of a court, the jurisdiction of judicial review extends only to decisions of inferior courts. It does not extend to decisions of the High Court or Court of Appeal. Judicial review must be used where you are seeking:

* a mandatory order (i.e. an order requiring the public body to do something and formerly known as an order of mandamus);
* a prohibiting order (i.e. an order preventing the public body from doing something and formerly known as an order of prohibition); or
* a quashing order (i.e. an order quashing the public body's decision and formerly known as an order of certiorari)
* a declaration
* HRA Damages

[Squicker]

Confirmed. The judgement went against us.

Did the judge explain why the judgement went against us?

[TykeMerc]

Truly sorry to hear that, everyone. Must be a huge disappointment.

Indeed, hopefully the detailed decision text will show the reasoning.

I'm very sad for you folks

[helen7]

So, will HMRC now send out demands for the money?