IR35 Forum - July minutes

[malvolio]

May I suggest you go back and re-read what James actually said over at the IPSE forums - I don't want to correct you on a public forum. Equally I suspect the problem may be less obvious in London / some departments than it is in say Longbenton.

But you know what people say about assumptions - on things like this we really shouldn't be making assumptions and should be pressing the point until we get an explicit confirmation...

So why are you debating the point on here, may I ask? Take this discussion where it belongs and we can discuss it properly. Come to that, the point about who was at the table was raised earlier and answered.

Or are you saying that with your extensive knowledge of HMRC operations, the various offices are taking no notice of what Head Office is telling them? In which case there is a whole other argument to be raised...

[eek]

So why are you debating the point on here, may I ask? Take this discussion where it belongs and we can discuss it properly. Come to that, the point about who was at the table was raised earlier and answered.

Or are you saying that with your extensive knowledge of HMRC operations, the various offices are taking no notice of what Head Office is telling them? In which case there is a whole other argument to be raised...

Reverse that last sentence and I suspect you are nearer the truth....

[poorautojobber]

A company I have worked for in the past used agency workers for manufacturing 'inside' the union forced them to convert them after 2 years to perm. Not sure if they just terminated them at 23 months I guess not otherwise they would have gone out on strike.
If/when this rolls out industry will be having kittens. My mind says they'd have to be stupid to even try but my heart says they will because 'HMRC'. Their will certainly be a few less conservative voters.

Didn't realise ipse had a forum and I'm a member!

[northernladuk]

A company I have worked for in the past used agency workers for manufacturing 'inside' the union forced them to convert them after 2 years to perm. Not sure if they just terminated them at 23 months I guess not otherwise they would have gone out on strike.
If/when this rolls out industry will be having kittens. My mind says they'd have to be stupid to even try but my heart says they will because 'HMRC'. Their will certainly be a few less conservative voters.

Didn't realise ipse had a forum and I'm a member!

Sounds more like they were on FTCs or something rather than B2B contracts like ours could be a different kettle of fish.

[mudskipper]

Didn't realise ipse had a forum and I'm a member!

Log into the IPSE website, then go to 'community' on your dashboard.

[TheFaQQer]

Log into the IPSE website, then go to 'community' on your dashboard.

Or go direct to http://community.ipse.co.uk