Reply to: How much is a human life worth?

[vetran]

Or, should we sacrifice the few to save the many? Lots of research and studies around this moral dilemma.

can we select the sacrificial lambs?

[DimPrawn]

Based on supply and demand, and rarity, I would put a human life at approximately zero.

Just pricing it up like a trader.

[Whorty]

How much is a car worth? How much is a house worth? Same principle, some are worthless some are worth a lot.

The real philosophical question to ask is, how many lives would you sacrifice to save your own life, or that of a loved one?

Or, should we sacrifice the few to save the many? Lots of research and studies around this moral dilemma.

[Old Greg]

Compensation claims always have to balance this and turn to cold, hard guidelines because there is no price you can put on the emotional loss.

A formula for calculating such a thing could look at age, health, level of education and level of wealth to determine an expected death date if it weren't brought forward in an untimely manner. From that, you could calculate how many years of contribution to the economy that were lost and multiply that by the median wage.

I'm pretty sure something like that already exists but I CBA to google for it.

Quality life years (QALY) used to be a thing. Not sure if they still are.

[ladymuck]

Compensation claims always have to balance this and turn to cold, hard guidelines because there is no price you can put on the emotional loss.

A formula for calculating such a thing could look at age, health, level of education and level of wealth to determine an expected death date if it weren't brought forward in an untimely manner. From that, you could calculate how many years of contribution to the economy that were lost and multiply that by the median wage.

I'm pretty sure something like that already exists but I CBA to google for it.

[NotAllThere]

£3.50 + VAT.

[SueEllen]

cow. I refer to my ex-wife....

Which one?

[DealorNoDeal]

How much is a human life worth?


If you're HMRC, not as much as the tax you owe.

[Zigenare]

How much is a human life worth?

Who to?

[Scruff]

cow. I refer to my ex-wife....

Which one...?

[Whorty]

Or maybe posters can suggest how much a kidney is worth?

Just the kidney, or do we include the steak and the pastry too?

[escapeUK]

How much is a car worth? How much is a house worth? Same principle, some are worthless some are worth a lot.

The real philosophical question to ask is, how many lives would you sacrifice to save your own life, or that of a loved one?

[BrilloPad]

lamb, cow or pig's kidney ??

cow. I refer to my ex-wife....

[BR14]

Or maybe posters can suggest how much a kidney is worth?

lamb, cow or pig's kidney ??

[BrilloPad]

Or maybe posters can suggest how much a kidney is worth?