Jon Venables to be freed

[Old Greg]

By 7 most children fully understand the basics, and why, not hurting other people is a big part of that.
By 2 they should know not to do it and that is perceived as wrong. They may forget but they know.



These boys are broken, it is a pity but I don't think there is any way to fix them.

And do they have the same understanding as adults of the consequences of their actions over a time period of 1 year into the future, or 10 years, or 50 years?

Would you like to see 7 year olds who kill tried as adults? 5 year olds? 4 year olds?

[suityou01]

And do they have the same understanding as adults of the consequences of their actions over a time period of 1 year into the future, or 10 years, or 50 years?

Would you like to see 7 year olds who kill tried as adults? 5 year olds? 4 year olds?

Could you rephrase, perhaps in another language? Give English a go perhaps.

[Old Greg]

WHS + infinity

Also, those on here that think they deserve sympathy and the ability to start over are also deeply deeply broken IMVHO.

I expect you would like to see 10 year olds executed if they kill, so you are the expert in brokenness.

[Old Greg]

Could you rephrase, perhaps in another language? Give English a go perhaps.

Nice rebuttal!

[d000hg]

So by that logic SY01, those children born and raised in a cellar after their captive mother was raped over multiple decades by a crazy Austrian should just be executed? Good to see you're expert enough to overturn the entire profession of psychiatry.

[MarillionFan]

I expect you would like to see 10 year olds executed if they kill, so you are the expert in brokenness.

So by that logic SY01, those children born and raised in a cellar after their captive mother was raped over multiple decades by a crazy Austrian should just be executed? Good to see you're expert enough to overturn the entire profession of psychiatry.

I think Suity is living in 16th century England.

Children & juvenile executions

Back then you could hang a child for stealing, the youngest being 7. In Suity's house he has a gallows next to the biscuit jar.

[vetran]

Then you're as bad as he is.

I was thinking that but didn't want to get the flak for saying so! I don't see why she has "to go through [that] again" - unless she means all the media bothering her.

maybe, just maybe she has managed an hour in a day when she hasn't thought about it since he has been locked up? Now he is free will her mind be filled again with images no mother should see?


At 10 you know what is wrong, why and that it will hurt other people.

[suityou01]

OK, are you sitting comfortably? Let's see if we can see from the recent posts what I think, shall we?

I expect you would like to see 10 year olds executed if they kill, so you are the expert in brokenness.

Hoooooooooooooooonk. I'm sorry that's a wrong answer. I'm passing control over to Doogie.

Doogie, what do you think I'm saying?

So by that logic SY01, those children born and raised in a cellar after their captive mother was raped over multiple decades by a crazy Austrian should just be executed? Good to see you're expert enough to overturn the entire profession of psychiatry.

Hoooooooooooooooonk. I'm sorry that's a wrong answer. Let's see if we can work it out from the quote below.

No, I would visit him as much as possible.

Thick as pig tulip this one

Any takers? Wanna go 50/50 or phone a friend?

[d000hg]

Sorry SY it was the part where you agreed with this "These boys are broken, it is a pity but I don't think there is any way to fix them."

I don't know how I got the idea that this meant you thought these people couldn't be fixed...

[suityou01]

I think Suity is living in 16th century England.

Children & juvenile executions

Back then you could hang a child for stealing, the youngest being 7. In Suity's house he has a gallows next to the biscuit jar.

Which is precisley why my children never steal biscuits.

Who am I kidding, the thieving little locusts. Hanging's too good for em.

Oops