Melanie Philips - what a moron.

[AtW]

Come on AtW you moron. Up your game a little this evening, otherwise you're going to find yourself in the position of CUK Village Idiot....again.

Given recent sockies it's the risk I am prepared to take ...

[MarillionFan]

Given recent sockies it's the risk I am prepared to take ...

To be honest, I'm surprised you gave it up. You've coverted the role for at least a decade. Janek gave you a run for your money as foreign loony for a few years but you've done well.

Reclaim your position! This village is missing one!

[AtW]

This village is missing one!

I reckon CUK is more of a town now...

[sasguru]

Certainly don't agree with everything MP says, esp on green issues but anyone who has ever read her stuff or listened to her and calls her stupid has to be severely rationally challenged. Who started this post? Oh right.

You mean it's rational to ignore the data, and when the charlatan you've been supporting is unmasked as a fraud, its logical to claim a conspiracy?

I understand you may be going a little senile, but don't be a complete tit, Xog.

[Sysman]

You mean it's rational to ignore the data, and when the charlatan you've been supporting is unmasked as a fraud, its logical to claim a conspiracy?

Got to agree with Xog here. She does knock out some sensible stuff so calling her a moron is definitely innappropriate.

[sasguru]

Got to agree with Xog here. She does knock out some sensible stuff so calling her a moron is definitely innappropriate.

She's definitely a moron on this issue. I'd like to know what sensible stuff you mean?

[Moscow Mule]

Got to agree with Xog here. She does knock out some sensible stuff so calling her a moron is definitely innappropriate.

Supporting Wakefield wipes out a lifetime of sensibleness.

[Gonzo]

Even if she is right about Londonistan.

I don't know whether she is a moron or not, and I don't much care.

I think she is vile. I started reading Londonistan but I was so outraged by its contents that I could not finish it. That would make me anti-semitic according to her arguments.

[sasguru]

I don't know whether she is a moron or not, and I don't much care.

I think she is vile. I started reading Londonistan but I was so outraged by its contents that I could not finish it. That would make me anti-semitic according to her arguments.

I hadn't read much of her other stuff before this morning.
She seems to be one of those ferociously pro-Israeli (and therefore rabidly anti-Muslim, which is probably why Xog likes her) British Jews.
The political stuff she writes seems to be a weaker mirror image of the fundamentalist Islamist bollux that all right-thinking people despise: she despises secularity and individualism and wants more religion, provided, of course, its not Islam.
Not the sharpest tool in the box, I'd say - unless controversy is how she makes her living in which case I'd call her profoundly immoral.

[Churchill]

My moneys on DP.
I've met SY and he's actually a rather nice bloke, but I suspect most of the posters on here are actually reasonable human beings in a social pup setting, I say most - there are one or two who I would probably bludgeon to death with a moldy cucumber given half a chance.

You got doggy on your mind?