Chico said:
I need some help from the our assembled bunch of IT professionals.What are the pro /cons of going for an inhouse developed IT solution compared with an off the shelf package? At the moment its all conceptual high level stuff so interested in general advice and any experiences in support of any particular option.
a) They do say that if you go for COTS (commercial off the shelf package) then be prepared to change the business to fit the package rather than the other way round.
b) If the COTS requires more than 20% changes to fit the business you might be better off doing bespoke.
c) Time to market, and is the solution tactical or strategic
d) Work out the trade-offs between bespoke and COTS, consider time, cost and risk
e) Understand the hidden costs with COTS e.g. most suppliers work on 50% product cost and 50% consultancy on top.
f) Products like SAP have a high ticket consultancy rate that needs to be added on top.
g) Look at the Total Cost of Ownership between the options over a number of years.
h) Consider what your competitors are doing within that line of business.
i) If you go for COTS then try and get the business to understand the compromises needed (to fit with the product) as well as the potential benefits e.g. potential reduced delivery risk.
j) Do a SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunites and Threats) analysis on the options.
k) Get the business to make the final decision and get them to own the outcome.
l) Decide (in terms of the COTS) what you can adopt (out of the box), what you need to adapt (change) and what is missing? e.g. what else do I need to buy.
m) Do not forget about integration
n) Think about data model compatability, conversion, migration etc.
o) Define an enterprise architecture so you understand the as-is the to-be and the associated transition steps.
p) And finally don't forget the COTS salesman and his bottle of snake oil!