Got it for Christmas - been playing it.
With the aid of side thrusters, which we didn't have in the original version - docking is a piece of cake - haven't scuffed the paintwork even once yet
Combat is incredibly hard - haven't got to grips with that yet.
As to general gameplay - mmm, I'll reserve judgement for a few weeks. Certainly I'm not sure I will be investing the time required to become Elite (again).
There are a few very annoying niggles, like being unable to Pause the game, even in Solo mode. Time continues even when you are not playing, so if you take on a mission which has 5 hours on it, you
have to complete within 5 hours real time, not 5 hours of gameplay.
It's not a game you can easily dip in and out of (unlike Skyrim etc.)
Biggest mistake is a common one - in business, not just video games - trying to do something half-hearted.
Either make it a MMOPRG, or don't. ED is trying to be both - and I don't think it works.