Brexit win - 11 threads into one

[AtW]

Only insofar conformance with the EU directives (that we have voted for, agreed to implement and adhere to, and in many cases also initiated) is concerned. It is not a supreme court for all areas of legislation.

EU court is supreme for agreed EU things, sounds fair and it's the only practical way - UK judges are taking part in EU court, it's not like it's German and French only.

[Old Greg]

I don't know what cloud you live on but the EU Courts have supremacy over ALL the states. The UK are incapable of repealing anything that is handed to them. Its like feeding a baby they hold our nose till we open our mouth and in goes the next spoon of tulip.

Its interesting that the most vocal supporters of the UK saying in this mess are all people that have chosen to leave the UK and work elsewhere. Perhaps you should just apply for residency in your new home and stay there.

Here in Realityland, the UK Parliament can repeal any law it wishes. Perhaps you are muddled between judiciary and legislature?

I don't need to apply for residency as it is automatic.

It's interesting that the most vocal supporters of the UK leaving the EU are stupid and/or ignorant.

[vetran]

It's interesting that most vocal supporters of the UK leaving the EU understand difference between fact and opinion,As an emmigrant remainer I can only make wild accusations and throw insults

FTFY

[Old Greg]

I don't know what cloud you live on but the EU Courts have supremacy over ALL the states. The UK are incapable of repealing anything that is handed to them. Its like feeding a baby they hold our nose till we open our mouth and in goes the next spoon of tulip.

Its interesting that the most vocal supporters of the UK saying in this mess are all people that have chosen to leave the UK and work elsewhere. Perhaps you should just apply for residency in your new home and stay there.

FTFY

So, vetran, do you believe that the EU Courts have supremacy over the UK Parliament?

[vetran]

So, vetran, do you believe that the EU Courts have supremacy over the UK Parliament?

do you?

https://fullfact.org/europe/eu-law-and-uk/

The UK has accepted the supremacy of EU law for some time

Other member countries have been more reluctant to accept the supremacy of EU law than the United Kingdom.

The European Communities Act, passed by Parliament in 1972, accepted the supremacy of EU law. That principle has also been endorsed by the UK courts.

As they seem to disagree with you they are obviously racist, xenophobic swivel eyed loons.

[Old Greg]

do you?

https://fullfact.org/europe/eu-law-and-uk/



As they seem to disagree with you they are obviously racist, xenophobic swivel eyed loons.

No, they state that EU law has supremacy over UK law, not over UK Parliament. That supremacy over UK law derives from UK Parliament, so UK Parliament can remove it through an Act of repeal for instance.

Do you understand now?

[DodgyAgent]

So, vetran, do you believe that the EU Courts have supremacy over the UK Parliament?

UK 'obliged' to accept judgments of European courts, official document from ministers ahead of EU referendum reveals

[DodgyAgent]

No, they state that EU law has supremacy over UK law, not over UK Parliament. That supremacy over UK law derives from UK Parliament, so UK Parliament can remove it through an Act of repeal for instance.

Do you understand now?

Why should we have to bother?

[AtW]

Why should we have to bother?

Rules of the club.

[Old Greg]

Rules of the club.

Which the UK Parliament can choose to leave at any point, reasserting the supremacy of UK law.