• Visitors can check out the Forum FAQ by clicking this link. You have to register before you can post: click the REGISTER link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. View our Forum Privacy Policy.
  • Want to receive the latest contracting news and advice straight to your inbox? Sign up to the ContractorUK newsletter here. Every sign up will also be entered into a draw to WIN £100 Amazon vouchers!
Collapse

You are not logged in or you do not have permission to access this page. This could be due to one of several reasons:

  • You are not logged in. If you are already registered, fill in the form below to log in, or follow the "Sign Up" link to register a new account.
  • You may not have sufficient privileges to access this page. Are you trying to edit someone else's post, access administrative features or some other privileged system?
  • If you are trying to post, the administrator may have disabled your account, or it may be awaiting activation.

Previously on "Are you a believer?"

Collapse

  • doodab
    replied
    Originally posted by northernladuk View Post
    Well there is that line of thinking, the other that Jedi Knight isn't really a religion and it is just a entry that shows you don't agree with the rest. Kind of spoiling your ballot paper and saying I am none of the above.

    Depends on whether you are geeky enough to really think you are a Jedi Knight or it is two fingers up to people that want you catagorised against a religion...
    I really wouldn't flatter that by describing it as a "line of thinking".

    Leave a comment:


  • xoggoth
    replied
    In fact it definitely did. I just discovered some long losts scrolls that prove it.

    Leave a comment:


  • xoggoth
    replied
    Give it a few hundred years and a regime that has a political interest in promoting it. Maybe Christianity started out as a puppet show.

    Leave a comment:


  • northernladuk
    replied
    Originally posted by doodab View Post
    Well, not really, it's a way of saying you believe in "an all powerful force that binds everything in the universe together". As they don't have a god as such, that would make them atheists, as most Buddhists are, wouldn't it?

    There ought to be some sort of "non-spiritual" category for the people who haven't thought about it and don't really want to. Anotgivashitstic or something.
    Well there is that line of thinking, the other that Jedi Knight isn't really a religion and it is just a entry that shows you don't agree with the rest. Kind of spoiling your ballot paper and saying I am none of the above.

    Depends on whether you are geeky enough to really think you are a Jedi Knight or it is two fingers up to people that want you catagorised against a religion...

    Wonder which one this dick is

    Political correctness strikes back: Jedi believer wins apology after being kicked out of Jobcentre for wearing a hood

    Leave a comment:


  • doodab
    replied
    Originally posted by northernladuk View Post
    Ok ok this is a discussion about not having a religion but putting yourself down as a Jedi is a away of not catagorising yourself as atheist/agnostic etc etc
    Well, not really, it's a way of saying you believe in "an all powerful force that binds everything in the universe together". As they don't have a god as such, that would make them atheists, as most Buddhists are, wouldn't it?

    There ought to be some sort of "non-spiritual" category for the people who haven't thought about it and don't really want to. Anotgivashitstic or something.

    Leave a comment:


  • northernladuk
    replied
    Where is Jedi Knight?

    Originally posted by TimberWolf View Post
    I don't believe in atheism or religion.
    I would tend to agree but the problem with society being based on belief, holidays, laws etc etc the only way to describe yourself would be to be part of a group that differentiates yourself to the other beliefs however stupid the concept may be.

    Anyway...

    Epic fail on the options. Where is Jedi Knight???

    390,000 people entered their religion as Jedi Knight (more than any of Sikhs, Buddhists or Jews), with some areas registering up to 2.6% of people as Jedi. Thus, 'Jedi' was fourth largest reported religion in the country
    Ok ok this is a discussion about not having a religion but putting yourself down as a Jedi is a away of not catagorising yourself as atheist/agnostic etc etc

    Leave a comment:


  • xoggoth
    replied
    What a most sensible post.

    Leave a comment:


  • meridian
    replied
    Originally posted by lilelvis2000 View Post
    I'm quite confused right now. Though I was born into a religion. I believe everyone needs a foundation of morals and ethics. As this doesn't come from the state one must get it from within or through another means. My parents did this through strict upbringing and religion.
    Humans are social animals. Examination of other social animals (chimps, dolphins, etc) show that there is an innate and inbuilt sense of duty towards the community in which they belong - those that act out of selfishness and do things that damage the tribe as a whole can be attacked and banished, or killed.

    Humans have an inbuilt sense of morals and ethics. However, as with other animals, if this morality is not nurtured and encouraged with society's own rules, the notion of what is acceptable and what is not can be blurred.


    Originally posted by lilelvis2000 View Post
    But I'm not sure I'm part of the 'right' religion and whether praying and the rituals makes any difference at all.
    Why would there be a "right" religion? You either believe what you've been told, or you don't, don't you? Both the Bible and Koran are full of nasty stuff, if you believe in one of them why would you only believe in the nicey-nicey and not the nasty?

    Originally posted by lilelvis2000 View Post
    Looking around me I see a society in complete decay. Morals and ethics thrown out the window. Materialism is THE goal of life. Respect of others, and particularly elders is almost non-existent.

    I witness my neighbour's young son. who is left to play out on the street on his own without supervision and is never chastised for his actions at all. The other week I spotted him throwing stones at my son and calling him names. When I complained to his parent I'm told "I'll have a word". This is the reality of England. 5 y/o's already into bullying, disrespect and negligent parenting.

    Could this be a result of religious decline and the selfish and materialistic drive now prevalent in society? Or is it simply a result of a divided society. I don't know.
    Bear in mind that under our society's rules, a 5 year old is incapable of making moral and ethical decisions. The parents are a different matter though.

    Being left to play on the street at 5 is not uncommon in mainland Europe. But the UK does seem to have a certain element of society that are determined to go their own way and sod the rest of us. Hopefully evolution will take care of them, but I fear that that will be too late for those of us having to deal with them now.

    Leave a comment:


  • doodab
    replied
    Originally posted by Ignis Fatuus View Post
    I disagree. Agnosticism is about god, atheism is not.

    Or shall we keep "atheist" for someone who positively believes that there is no god?

    Then an agnostic is someone who believes that there may be a god but he doesn't and can't know anything about god.

    Someone who isn't sure whether there is a god, but thinks that there might be, and it might be possible to know, is not an agnostic but a believer suffering doubt.

    And what about someone who simply does not believe in god and has no time for the idea, but who does not hold as an article of faith that there is no god? If you call him either an atheist or an agnostic, you are forcing him into a religious classification, whereas the simple fact is that he is not religious.
    An agnostic is one who believes the question cannot be definitely answered. That covers a whole spectrum of belief from the "rational atheist" stance that MTT has through those who simply refuse to commit either way to the believer with doubts.

    There is another line dividing the strongly agnostic position that the question cannot ever be definitely answered (which involves it's own leap of faith) from those who believe that we may in fact be able to answer it one day.

    An atheist would assert that there is no god. One can be an agnostic atheist in the same way a believer can doubt his faith, but both are also agnostics of some degree.

    Leave a comment:


  • xoggoth
    replied
    I believe everyone needs a foundation of morals and ethics. As this doesn't come from the state one must get it from within or through another means
    Proper upbringing by parents teaching practical rules to enable us to get along should be enough surely? This is another area where religion seems to do nothing, the behaviour of children most clearly relates to practical factors, like prosperity and a stable loving family of two parents, not to their faith.

    Think you are right on divided society, from elsewhere in the world social conflicts appear to be more of a factor in criminality than poverty.

    Leave a comment:


  • xoggoth
    replied
    Human society is about chosing sides and I think one sometimes has to make a firm decision about what you are going to believe even when there is no good reason.

    Unfortunately, if there is a conflict of opinion and the outcome affects you in practical ways, you may not have a choice. Even if you think both viewpoints are idiotic, you have to go with the one that is least objectionable.

    Personally, I find Dawkins and some others fanatical, non belief is like a religion with them. I'd still back them against the religious as (so far) I don't see them interfering in the law to get their views imposed on the rest of us.

    Leave a comment:


  • lilelvis2000
    replied
    I'm quite confused right now. Though I was born into a religion. I believe everyone needs a foundation of morals and ethics. As this doesn't come from the state one must get it from within or through another means. My parents did this through strict upbringing and religion. But I'm not sure I'm part of the 'right' religion and whether praying and the rituals makes any difference at all.

    Looking around me I see a society in complete decay. Morals and ethics thrown out the window. Materialism is THE goal of life. Respect of others, and particularly elders is almost non-existent.

    I witness my neighbour's young son. who is left to play out on the street on his own without supervision and is never chastised for his actions at all. The other week I spotted him throwing stones at my son and calling him names. When I complained to his parent I'm told "I'll have a word". This is the reality of England. 5 y/o's already into bullying, disrespect and negligent parenting.

    Could this be a result of religious decline and the selfish and materialistic drive now prevalent in society? Or is it simply a result of a divided society. I don't know.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ignis Fatuus
    replied
    Originally posted by xoggoth View Post
    Ignis Fatuus

    Not Bader meinhoff but a fairly recent EU report on terrorism shows that left wing groups are the main terrorists after separatists.

    http://www.europol.europa.eu/publica.../TESAT2009.pdf

    See also recent threats in Greece.
    I stand corrected, insofar as I can allow such a thing to happen.


    (I can believe six impossible things before breakfast, but I'll be damned if I'll admit to six mistakes before teatime).

    Leave a comment:


  • xoggoth
    replied
    Ignis Fatuus

    Not Bader meinhoff but a fairly recent EU report on terrorism shows that left wing groups are the main terrorists after separatists.

    http://www.europol.europa.eu/publica.../TESAT2009.pdf

    See also recent threats in Greece.
    Last edited by xoggoth; 29 September 2010, 11:06.

    Leave a comment:


  • Platypus
    replied
    Originally posted by lukemg View Post
    it's hilarious that people cling to such beliefs while marvelling at the stupidity of ancient civilisations worshipping the sun and nature etc
    Amen to that!

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X