Reply to: Anyone else following the Goldacre Vs McKeith twitter fight?

[NickFitz]

Good work Nick ;-) Just read your post on JoK

Cheers

[norrahe]

Hell yes. This ain't charity.

Wanna buy some water? It had some 'stuff' in it once and I'm sure it remembers all about it.

This sums it all up really

[DS23]

no

[Pondlife]

Do you charge extra for looking at people's excrement?

I betcha thats where she makes her money

Hell yes. This ain't charity.

Wanna buy some water? It had some 'stuff' in it once and I'm sure it remembers all about it.

[norrahe]

True. I am also a nutritionist and using the non Dr's logic, I am recommending all basketball players eat kangaroo meat. If you want to be taller and thinner, eat snakes.

That'll be £50 please.

HTH (BIW)

Do you charge extra for looking at people's excrement?

I betcha thats where she makes her money

[TheFaQQer]

Good work Nick ;-) Just read your post on JoK

Good lord, Nick - two blog posts in a year!! It must be serious

[Pondlife]

Good work Nick ;-) Just read your post on JoK

[Bunk]

True. I am also a nutritionist and using the non Dr's logic, I am recommending all basketball players eat kangaroo meat. If you want to be taller and thinner, eat snakes.

That'll be £50 please.

HTH (BIW)

Nice, but for double boomed, you should also start selling the kangaroo meat. Now that's a Plan B.

[Pondlife]

I heard on the radio the other day that you should always be wary of someone who refers to themselves as a nutritionist. The term dietician is legally protected like doctor or dentist but anyone can call themself a nutritionist. Assuming that's true, I'm guessing McKeith is a nutritionist.

True. I am also a nutritionist and using the non Dr's logic, I am recommending all basketball players eat kangaroo meat. If you want to be taller and thinner, eat snakes.

That'll be £50 please.

HTH (BIW)

[Bunk]

I heard on the radio the other day that you should always be wary of someone who refers to themselves as a nutritionist. The term dietician is legally protected like doctor or dentist but anyone can call themself a nutritionist. Assuming that's true, I'm guessing McKeith is a nutritionist.

[shaunbhoy]

just focus on someone who can be easily targeted by an ever hungry media.

Nice one. Saw what you did there!!

[norrahe]

There are plenty of men named and shamed in Goldacre's book Bad Science - Professor Patrick Holford gets a whole chapter to himself for the rubbish he talks about nutrition (including claiming that Vitamin C is more effective against HIV than AZT is), and the chapter about Matthias Rath (who persuaded the South African government that garlic was an effective cure for AIDS and "Western" medicines were poison) had to be left out of the first edition because he sued Goldacre and The Grauniad for libel in a case that cost them around £500,000 before it was finally thrown out.

Thank you.

The problem is people seem to focus on Ms McKeith, rather than the more serious issues addressed by the book and just focus on someone who can be easily targeted by an ever hungry media.

[shaunbhoy]

Gillian McKeith?
Jeezus, I would not trust her to count her tits and get the same number twice!!!

[MarillionFan]

Gillian McKeith: You are what you tweet

Thought you were losing the plot there without a link!

[NickFitz]

Gillian McKeith: You are what you tweet