Reply to: Spain says 'closer to' controlling Gibraltar after Brexit vote

[NotAllThere]

Another contender.

No one stopping them living in Britain....

No ones stopping you from moving from Neasden to Truro either. But you'd mighty pissed off if you suddenly had to or be ruled by the Spanish.

[NotAllThere]

Maybe I misread the meaning of 19,300 remain vs 800 to leave then.

Indeed you have.

For the hard of thinking, let me explain. While you may think that a vote to remain in the EU indicates that someone doesn't want to be British, Remain voters don't agree. In fact, I'd contend that the majority of Brexit voters wouldn't agree either.

When they were asked if they would like to be British, joint British/Spanish or even just Spanish, the Gibraltans democratically and resoundingly said that they wanted to continue to be British. In conjunction with their remain vote, this indicates that they want to

a) Continue to be ruled by Britain
b) Continue to be part of the EU.

Again, you might think these are mutually exclusive alternatives, to many many people, they are not.

I hope that clears up your confusion.

One reason, I think, why they particularly wanted to be in the EU, is that EU membership makes it a lot harder for Spain to press their claim.

Please accept my most humble apologies

Accepted.

[RetSet]

Well done. Pig ignorant post of the day. There's been quite a few, but yours is clearly the winner.

Maybe I misread the meaning of 19,300 remain vs 800 to leave then.

EU referendum: Gibraltar backs Remain in first result of the night | UK Politics | News | The Independent

Please accept my most humble apologies

[NotAllThere]

That's not how they voted yesterday...

Well done. Pig ignorant post of the day. There's been quite a few, but yours is clearly the winner.

[RetSet]

you don't seem to understand they actually want to be linked to the British and have confirmed so democratically.

That's not how they voted yesterday...

[vetran]

If Scotland leave the UK we give them Gibraltar and the Falklands.

After all Scotland had a few little islands so a few more pieces of land would be OK.

though the SNP will probably sell them for beans when the books don't balance.

[SueEllen]

as I say part of brexit may need to be investigating what we do with Gibraltar & Scotland.

If Scotland leave the UK we give them Gibraltar and the Falklands.

After all Scotland had a few little islands so a few more pieces of land would be OK.

[vetran]

They also didn't want to leave the EU.... tulip happens

as I say part of brexit may need to be investigating what we do with Gibraltar & Scotland.

[dx4100]

that is not what they want.

They also didn't want to leave the EU.... tulip happens

[vetran]

No one stopping them living in Britain....

that is not what they want.

If we are going to unravel sovereign nations based on who owned it 200 years ago we could take back half the world.

[vetran]

Why not just ask the inhabitants if they want:
Spanish rule
UK rule
Joint rule

Any option getting over 50% changes the status quo.

Same for Falklands but swap Spanish for Argentine

already been done.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibraltar

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falkla...eignty_dispute


now if they wanted to be truly independent and remain in the EU maybe that is something we need to ask them during Brexit. Obviously once independent it wouldn't be surprising if they got invaded without our protection.

[dx4100]

you don't seem to understand they actually want to be linked to the British and have confirmed so democratically.

No one stopping them living in Britain....

[vetran]

Its all a bit silly that we pretend its ours... Same goes for the Falklands...

Sensible thing is to agree joint ownership etc...

you don't seem to understand they actually want to be linked to the British and have confirmed so democratically.

[LondonManc]

Why not just ask the inhabitants if they want:
Spanish rule
UK rule
Joint rule

Any option getting over 50% changes the status quo.

Same for Falklands but swap Spanish for Argentine

[BrilloPad]

Guess it'll be up to the Gibraltarians to decide, do they want to:

a) Have their Cake;
b) Eat it;
c) Both of the above.

Why can't the rest of the UK decide if we want to keep them?