Client decides role is inside IR35 but then fails to deduct any taxes

[dingdong]

I already appealed including evidence of use of multiple substitutions (along with documentary evidence of their acceptance of substitutes). My appeal was rejected without any reasons being provided.

Just goes to show how the whole process is flawed.

If you believe an assessment is still factually incorrect there is nothing further you can do - other than perhaps take them to an employment tribunal when you leave the gig!! I doubt HMRC would ever hand the taxes paid back though!

[eek]

I already appealed including evidence of use of multiple substitutions (along with documentary evidence of their acceptance of substitutes). My appeal was rejected without any reasons being provided.

Just goes to show how the whole process is flawed.

If you believe an assessment is still factually incorrect there is nothing further you can do - other than perhaps take them to an employment tribunal when you leave the gig!! I doubt HMRC would ever hand the taxes paid back though!

There is no formal mechanism of appeal.

Personally if I had been told my contract was inside IR35 I would have left in April for there would be very big problems were HMRC to come calling.