Edge EBT thread

[gettingangry]

Come on I urge everyone to submit a Data Protection request.

https://online.hmrc.gov.uk/shortforms/form/DPU_SAR

Check you get a email confirmation

[bstar1]

How are you appealing ? Letter sent to APN team detailing the incorrect inclusion in their calculations ?

yes

[sl4]

I'm appealing this with HMRC and a decision will be made in Oct.

How are you appealing ? Letter sent to APN team detailing the incorrect inclusion in their calculations ?

[bstar1]

If the general consensus is that loan BIK should not be included in the APN calculations, what advice is their regarding getting it removed ? Appeal to HMRC, quick phone call ? How accommodating are they about

1. understanding what it actually is
2. removing it ?

I'm appealing this with HMRC and a decision will be made in Oct.

[sl4]

How to get BIK Removed

The answer is NO. The BIK is due to the loans. If they say they are not loans there can be no BIK.

I had one APN figure reduced because the APN dept realised it was an error. Although they didn't bother on 2 other APNs - which just about sums up the incompetence of these people. However, the Settlement dept re-issued figures still including the BIK - called them to get it removed - but they are even more incompetent and struggled to understand the issue. Waiting for a reply.

If the general consensus is that loan BIK should not be included in the APN calculations, what advice is their regarding getting it removed ? Appeal to HMRC, quick phone call ? How accommodating are they about

1. understanding what it actually is
2. removing it ?

[Dylan]

Didn't you get the memo? You are guilty by default! they have nothing to win.

Even if I didn't get the memo I'm sure HMRC could produce the one they "sent" 8 years ago

[DotasScandal]

The money should'nt appear in their accounts as collected, it isn't theirs until they win the case.

Didn't you get the memo? You are guilty by default! they have nothing to win.

[Dylan]

HMRC vindicated over Accelerated Payment Notices :: Contractor UK

The money should'nt appear in their accounts as collected, it isn't theirs until they win the case.

[IPMAN]

Pay now argue later ok !

HMRC vindicated over Accelerated Payment Notices :: Contractor UK

[Tweedle]

I'd agree.

Please note that there is NO CORRELATION between APN and CLSO values.

I think we all have proof of the above, but don't you think there SHOULD be...aren't they ultimately talking about the same EBT loans or income, don't they all have access to the same information and shouldn't a calculation of tax owed in HMRCs opinion be consistent, however they are trying to demand it??