HMRC emails - Loancharge Debacle - Freedom of Information

[dammit chloe]

HMRC has bottomless financial resources, and an even deeper ego. They will appeal anything to its absolute end.

When they appeal Hoey's UT decision and if Hoey cannot meet the legal cost its the end for all of us pre 2010. HMRC will have then the power to demand all taxes they claim are due with no further recourse from the taxpayer. That is why its in the benefit of all PRE-2010 individuals to support this legal fund appeal;

https://www.gofundme.com/f/hoey-cour...ource=customer

I understand that. I am trying to understand what state the appeals or lack of appeals leaves as the status quo. The UT has said that CC is the best place to resolve and has directed its judgement that there is no tax to pay. That is that standing precedent as of this moment. Does this precedent change with an appeal? Or could it be the case that the whole process could be started over if HMRC try to collect from someone else in the same way?

The PAYE credit issue doesn't seem to have been resolved, finally, either way.

[luxCon]

I understand that. I am trying to understand what state the appeals or lack of appeals leaves as the status quo. The UT has said that CC is the best place to resolve and has directed its judgement that there is no tax to pay. That is that standing precedent as of this moment. Does this precedent change with an appeal? Or could it be the case that the whole process could be started over if HMRC try to collect from someone else in the same way?

The PAYE credit issue doesn't seem to have been resolved, finally, either way.

I cant answer specifics as I'm no expert. However have you read the following threads below by Matt who is Hoey's tax advisor? It may contain the answers you looking for. Other than that talk to Matt on Twitter @ArmadilloSupprt , he is pretty good at engaging and replies


https://forums.contractoruk.com/hmrc...ml#post2875351

https://forums.contractoruk.com/hmrc...ml#post2875421