Look at it this way. Based on the information provided, the probability of being inside is somewhere in [0,1]. At what probability does the QDOS reviewer classify the outcome as FAIL?
Obviously, you don't want a reviewer coming to conclusions that are inconsistent with what the vast majority of competent reviewers might conclude, but there's always going to be some difference in opinion. It appears that you've either been given a bad review (as in, found an obsessively sensitive reviewer) or that the information you've reported here is misleading, i.e. that several other factors were borderline too. That being said, I don't really know what you want from us? If it's just an FYI, fine -thanks If you're unhappy with the review, send it elsewhere. Personally, I'm not a massive fan of the QDOS reviews, except as a cheap/formal confirmation of due diligence for the simplest/shortest contracts that I already know to be way outside. This is nothing more than personal opinion though. YMMV.
Obviously, you don't want a reviewer coming to conclusions that are inconsistent with what the vast majority of competent reviewers might conclude, but there's always going to be some difference in opinion. It appears that you've either been given a bad review (as in, found an obsessively sensitive reviewer) or that the information you've reported here is misleading, i.e. that several other factors were borderline too. That being said, I don't really know what you want from us? If it's just an FYI, fine -thanks If you're unhappy with the review, send it elsewhere. Personally, I'm not a massive fan of the QDOS reviews, except as a cheap/formal confirmation of due diligence for the simplest/shortest contracts that I already know to be way outside. This is nothing more than personal opinion though. YMMV.
Comment