Reply to: Stone Roses reunited and touring.

[Spacecadet]

Erm the roses were initially from Widnes not Manchester

It's Manchester, not sure where you get Widnes from

[TheFaQQer]

You can guarantee that they will put their all into the performances. Seeing as their bank manager will be in the crowd...

[rsingh]

You can guarantee that they will put their all into the performances. Seeing as their bank manager will be in the crowd...

[original PM]

Over rated Manchester band.

Almost as bad as the Happy Mondays.

www.marillion.com

Erm the roses were initially from Widnes not Manchester

I would go the concert but I am just to old to get bottles of p*ss thrown at me...

[TheFaQQer]

Marillion Maith.

Another MF sockie?

[cailin maith]

Everyone get tickets?

I did

[Incognito]

I was there it was truly dreadful, I hope he's spent the last 15 years having singing lessons

Stories go he'd been caning it all night and day prior to going on the stage. Look at the nick of him. I'll give him that tulip night.

I'll be poised 09.25 on Friday. 4 tickets coming up.

[TiroFijo]

Over rated Manchester band.

Almost as bad as the Happy Mondays.

www.marillion.com

No no no no no no no.................no
Even when your hero Fish was their frontman they were tulip.

[Bagpuss]

I was there it was truly dreadful, I hope he's spent the last 15 years having singing lessons

P.S there were some funny moments, like when some Oasis wannabe 'fan' was making it unpleasant for others he stopped and got security to throw him and his mates out.

[Pondlife]

He seems to have his head back on (well it's all relative)

[Pondlife]

You're almost certainly right Baggy, all of the live stuff I've ever seen on TV/Youtube doesn't do the songs justice.

But, for someone of my (our?) age group, you can't not go.

[Bagpuss]

Yeah good studio band, but terrible live band with him 'singing'. Add to that the twats who like oasis tagging along to the gigs, it won't be great. If they make an album that could be good though.

[MarillionFan]

The Stone Roses - ******* tulipe, can't wait to pull out my own teeth

ftfy

[Incognito]

The Stone Roses - ******* class, can't wait.

[Bagpuss]

Oh Yes.

Got some bad news for you. Ian Brown can't sing live, well not in tune anyway. As much as the songs were good his performance is probably the worst I have ever seen.


"lets get this straight, the only thing wrong with the reading gig was Ian's vocals.

i was there too and the anticipation when the 1st few bars of I wanna be adored were played were spine tingling good, only to to be washed away by the 1st few bars of the lyrics- people were visibly shocked at how out of tune and key he was that night, people were turning to each other with dismay and shock... at the vocals, not at the music!!"

http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2011...?newsfeed=true