Reply to: Political Compass - Who are you like?

[BigRed]

So it looks like I need to vote for Nelson Mandela / Gandhi. But all the politicians seem to be top right.

[hyperD]

Economic Left/Right: -3.62
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -4.26

Roughly the same as last time - possibly one notch to the right of Gandhi now - I blame CUK!

But you did give me some German cookies, so it's true!

[mudskipper]

I've filed you under liberal for after the revolution.

Economic Left/Right: -3.62
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -4.26

Roughly the same as last time - possibly one notch to the right of Gandhi now - I blame CUK!

[hyperD]

Also, what HyperD said.

Thanks! Just to reiterate...

Did mine a few times over the years - I'm consistently in the bottom right hand square which makes sense to me I guess.

Do hate the lazy pejoratives of "left" and "right". They have been distorted many times over many axes over many years. Encouraged and exaggerated by the media, "Right wing [fascist]" seems to mean anyone who isn't into burning money tree offerings to the NHS, against "saving whales, saving snails" and against bigger state and high taxation whilst the "left" appear to be anyone that supports the growing state, prizes for all, keep shaking the infinite money tree and damn the "rich", whoever they may be.

The problem is, whomever you vote will carry on increasing taxes, growing the state, supporting the Corporatocracy and increasing the burdening legislation we have to suffer in all aspects of business and personal life.

The punch and judy show between the red shirts and the blue shirts is a mere distraction to the growing cancer of state intervention into every aspect of our affairs.

Most of us want a reasonable balance of state management and personal freedoms but the divide between the two camps is quickly turning into some kind of Peter Jackson parody.

[Old Greg]

Me and Gandhi - political peas in a pod.

I've filed you under liberal for after the revolution.

[Zero Liability]

The left-right scale in the test is supposed to be economic, so the traditional kind of anarchists would be bottom-left while anarcho-capitalists like myself -should- be bottom right. Kindof.

Murray Rothbard wrote (pdf link here at the Mises institute - Murray N. Rothbard :: Left, Right, and the Prospects for Liberty) about how libertarianism doesn't fall into the left-right paradigm at all (in the context of a single left-right scale, rather than the 2 dimensional scale in this test).

This misunderstanding shows in the test because alot of the questions don't even make sense from a anarcho-capitalist/voluntarist/market anarchist/minarchist perspective (the word libertarian these days is so broadly defined as to be meaningless, so i didn't use it) - which is why I said 'kindof' earlier.

Ditto. Just because I am a market anarchist (voluntaryist more generally) doesn't mean I approve of government-subsidised MNCs, either, so some of the questions in the test are misleading or simply irrelevant to me, otherwise I'd score something like 10, -10.

Also, what HyperD said.

[Mich the Tester]

The punch and judy show between the red shirts and the blue shirts is a mere distraction to the growing cancer of state intervention into every aspect of our affairs.

WHS

[aardvark]

Me and Gandhi - political peas in a pod.

WSS

[hyperD]

Did mine a few times over the years - I'm consistently in the bottom right hand square which makes sense to me I guess.

Do hate the lazy pejoratives of "left" and "right". They have been distorted many times over many axes over many years. Encouraged and exaggerated by the media, "Right wing [fascist]" seems to mean anyone who isn't into burning money tree offerings to the NHS, against "saving whales, saving snails" and against bigger state and high taxation whilst the "left" appear to be anyone that supports the growing state, prizes for all, keep shaking the infinite money tree and damn the "rich", whoever they may be.

The problem is, whomever you vote will carry on increasing taxes, growing the state, supporting the Corporatocracy and increasing the burdening legislation we have to suffer in all aspects of business and personal life.

The punch and judy show between the red shirts and the blue shirts is a mere distraction to the growing cancer of state intervention into every aspect of our affairs.

Most of us want a reasonable balance of state management and personal freedoms but the divide between the two camps is quickly turning into some kind of Peter Jackson parody.

[d000hg]

here's my result:

Almost identical here.

[MicrosoftBob]

I got this:

http://www.politicalcompass.org/face...1.12&soc=-3.59

I always thought I was more of a right wing libertarian, so a bit suprised it makes me Nelson Mandela

[MyUserName]

I am a leftie libertarian, which I am a little surprised about!

Economic Left/Right: -3.00
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -2.36

[SpontaneousOrder]

Left and right always confusing. How were the Nazis right if it stood for National Socialism? How are anarchists who hate state control lefties?

The left-right scale in the test is supposed to be economic, so the traditional kind of anarchists would be bottom-left while anarcho-capitalists like myself -should- be bottom right. Kindof.

Murray Rothbard wrote (pdf link here at the Mises institute - Murray N. Rothbard :: Left, Right, and the Prospects for Liberty) about how libertarianism doesn't fall into the left-right paradigm at all (in the context of a single left-right scale, rather than the 2 dimensional scale in this test).

This misunderstanding shows in the test because alot of the questions don't even make sense from a anarcho-capitalist/voluntarist/market anarchist/minarchist perspective (the word libertarian these days is so broadly defined as to be meaningless, so i didn't use it) - which is why I said 'kindof' earlier.

[realityhack]

That looks like a good place for a moderator to be!

I'm surprised - thought I'd be more right wing/libertarian. Anyhow, just happy I'm not a Marxist!

[thunderlizard]

That looks like a good place for a moderator to be!