Reply to: Re-opening the Wilmslow "Is he real" debate:

[AtW]

And I won the pub quiz in his ''local' .Are we even o sockpuppet of mine?

Maybe.

[Zippy]

And Tolkien grew up just few miles away from AtW's "bedsit"...

And I won the pub quiz in his ''local' .Are we even o sockpuppet of mine?

[AtW]

But I am still convinced "he" is a Tolkien like genius.........

And Tolkien grew up just few miles away from AtW's "bedsit"...

[AtW]

All I said was that he is real.

You should not jump to conclusions and consider other possibilities.

[Peoplesoft bloke]

But I am still convinced "he" is a Tolkien like genius.........

I agree - apart from anything else, any engagement the poster who posts as Wilmslow makes with any responses or respondents to his inane ramblings don't follow a logical - or even illogical but recognisably characteristic pattern. A number of us have tried to engage him in rational debate on some of the topics raised and the trail goes dead very quickly - always. Most people (and sockpuppets) on here will either debate a point with you or else at least question your intelligence and/or sanity if you disagree with them.

[Drewster]

Sorry about that. I of course meant Wilmslow.

But I am still convinced "he" is a Tolkien like genius.........

[Churchill]

Oi! I might have another Userid.... and why would meeting me.... Oh Oooops! You didn't mean me did you?

Sorry about that. I of course meant Wilmslow.

[Drewster]

All I said was that he is real.

I was responding to Drewster. I doubt he has another userid on here. If you'd met him you'd understand why.

Oi! I might have another Userid.... and why would meeting me.... Oh Oooops! You didn't mean me did you?

[Churchill]

And that proves that he isn't additionally another poster? How?

All I said was that he is real.

I was responding to Drewster. I doubt he has another userid on here. If you'd met him you'd understand why.

[cailin maith]

And that proves that he isn't additionally another poster? How?

What does it matter, he is still Wilmslow

[TheFaQQer]

For the record he didn't turn up and say "I'm Wilmslow".

What actually happened was that a guy walked past our table who I thought was Wilmslow-like. He rounded the corner and was out of sight, I shouted "Wilmsloooowwwww!" and he came back.

He is real.

And that proves that he isn't additionally another poster? How?

[Churchill]

No, I don't.

If I had turned up and said "I'm XX" and posted a couple of times as XX saying I was in the pub, that would prove that I was XX. It would not prove that I wasn't anyone else.

Wilmslow turned up to the pub, but that is no evidence that he isn't a creation of another poster.

For the record he didn't turn up and say "I'm Wilmslow".

What actually happened was that a guy walked past our table who I thought was Wilmslow-like. He rounded the corner and was out of sight, I shouted "Wilmsloooowwwww!" and he came back.

He is real.

[MaryPoppins]

You sure it wasnt really the guy Menaleus(?) you were all banging on about last week, and he's taken you for a ride again?

Can't have been, cos we know what he looks like.

[MarillionFan]

No, I don't.

If I had turned up and said "I'm XX" and posted a couple of times as XX saying I was in the pub, that would prove that I was XX. It would not prove that I wasn't anyone else.

Wilmslow turned up to the pub, but that is no evidence that he isn't a creation of another poster.

You sure it wasnt really the guy Menaleus(?) you were all banging on about last week, and he's taken you for a ride again?

[TheFaQQer]

you miss the point. we are not talking about labels here, it really was Wilmslow

if you see what I mean

No, I don't.

If I had turned up and said "I'm XX" and posted a couple of times as XX saying I was in the pub, that would prove that I was XX. It would not prove that I wasn't anyone else.

Wilmslow turned up to the pub, but that is no evidence that he isn't a creation of another poster.