Interview Feedback

[jmo21]

If I apply for a role and am not progressed for interview, then fair enough I do not expect to hear back from the agent. However, if I apply for a role, am offered an interview and then go to the interview, I then expect the agent to provide feedback regardless of whether successful or not. This should be part of the service the agent is providing.

I am not saying in this instance this is what has happened, only that it looks like a no go and I want to discuss with the agent, hopefully on Monday if I can get hold of him.

Appreciate the steer you are trying to provide, I trust the above clarifies the point I am trying to make.

We know what you are wanting from them, but sadly that is not how it works, in contracting certainly, in permie interviews it can be typical too.

The agent is not providing you a service, and if you don't get the role then he couldn't give a crap about anything other than how to get one of his other candidates in (though, maybe yes, he is putting off talking to you to keep you as a backup)

What exactly do you think he will tell you? Do you think the interviewer (or whoever at client co) will tell him exactly the reasons x y and z? Even if he does, do you think the recruiter will want to tell you?

Now, some agents will give you feedback, but most won't -as others have said, if you have the role, they'll be all over you.

[RichardCranium]

I always seem to get the urge to sabotage the next candidates by giving the agent bad advice. For example, telling the agent that the interviewer had comedy socks and tie on and seemed disappointed at my sober interview attire.

Oh, that was YOU was it?






I like it ... evil grin.

[craig1]

YEP!

I don't even bother ringing the agent post interview - they only want to know what questions were asked so they can prime another candidate.

If they want me - I can't get rid of 'em.

Tone

I always seem to get the urge to sabotage the next candidates by giving the agent bad advice. For example, telling the agent that the interviewer had comedy socks and tie on and seemed disappointed at my sober interview attire.

[MarillionFan]

Thanks guys. Yes am basing on the fact that this will come to nothing, but still want to speak to the agent next week to tell him what an incompetent idiot he is...

At the end of the day, you weren't competitive or experienced enough.

In the market place there is always someone better than you who gets the gig if you don't.

If you do get the gig everytime. Then you're me.

[HeadOfTesting]

If I apply for a role and am not progressed for interview, then fair enough I do not expect to hear back from the agent. However, if I apply for a role, am offered an interview and then go to the interview, I then expect the agent to provide feedback regardless of whether successful or not. This should be part of the service the agent is providing.

I am not saying in this instance this is what has happened, only that it looks like a no go and I want to discuss with the agent, hopefully on Monday if I can get hold of him.

Appreciate the steer you are trying to provide, I trust the above clarifies the point I am trying to make.

I've had cases where I have gone through to final interview for senior perm roles and still not got (or chased) feedback. Poor form (and stupid since I'm a potential client to a recruiter) but there you go. My policy is to never chase feedback - if you're still in the game the agent will be all over you like a rash.

[kaiser78]

How?

You're a jobbing IT bod and attended a business meeting to sell your services, as did a bunch of others. You specified your rate and said what you'd do or how you would do it.

How is that different from Billy the Brick coming round and giving you a quote for a conservatory because the Missus wants one built?

If I apply for a role and am not progressed for interview, then fair enough I do not expect to hear back from the agent. However, if I apply for a role, am offered an interview and then go to the interview, I then expect the agent to provide feedback regardless of whether successful or not. This should be part of the service the agent is providing.

I am not saying in this instance this is what has happened, only that it looks like a no go and I want to discuss with the agent, hopefully on Monday if I can get hold of him.

Appreciate the steer you are trying to provide, I trust the above clarifies the point I am trying to make.

[Tingles]

How?

You're a jobbing IT bod and attended a business meeting to sell your services, as did a bunch of others. You specified your rate and said what you'd do or how you would do it.

How is that different from Billy the Brick coming round and giving you a quote for a conservatory because the Missus wants one built?

YEP!

I don't even bother ringing the agent post interview - they only want to know what questions were asked so they can prime another candidate.

If they want me - I can't get rid of 'em.

Tone

[RichardCranium]

Different scenario.

How?

You're a jobbing IT bod and attended a business meeting to sell your services, as did a bunch of others. You specified your rate and said what you'd do or how you would do it.

How is that different from Billy the Brick coming round and giving you a quote for a conservatory because the Missus wants one built?

[kaiser78]

When you get builders / decorators / removals people to come round and give quotes, do you 'phone all the unsuccessful ones, or just the one you want to do the job?

Different scenario.

[RichardCranium]

When you get builders / decorators / removals people to come round and give quotes, do you 'phone all the unsuccessful ones, or just the one you want to do the job?

[kaiser78]

Thanks guys. Yes am basing on the fact that this will come to nothing, but still want to speak to the agent next week to tell him what an incompetent idiot he is...

[Zippy]

WTOSH1S

The agent would have been all over the client and if there had been good news you would have heard.
Agents nearly always say the client will make a quick decision and (shock horror) that may not always be the truth.
Another possibility is that they are keeping you in reserve in case their first choice turns it down.

For the sake of your sanity, I would assume you haven't got it, and press on with finding something else. It may still come good, but I really wouldn't hang about.

All the best!

[TOSH1]

Im not sure that you will get any feed back on Monday if any at all. You either get a positive or negative responce either the same day or the next day. I'm still waiting to hear about an interview i went to, the interview seemed keen to for me to start, then before i left said he just had to confirm with his manager about costs, Im still waiting to hera on this one.

Hope you get the job on Monday though

[kaiser78]

I had an interview for a contract role earlier this week, for which the client co had advised they were looking to make a quick decision by end of thursday with a view to starting asap.

So Thursday comes and goes, nothing. I did check with the agency on Thursday am and they said they were expecting to hear that day. Chased again on Fri am and was told the agent would ring back. I emailed and left a voicemail for him asking for an update. I then found out he was at client meetings on Fri afternoon.

So I do not know if my interview has been successful or not. The mind starts playing games - maybe the agent hasn't heard back and so has not returned my call, maybe the role has been given to someone else and so has not returned my call, maybe he is are busy at client meetings and have simply not had the chance to chase/update ? etc etc.

Either way I do not have a good feeling about this, especially from past experience with agents but will wait until Monday when hopefully I will get a positive update...