• Visitors can check out the Forum FAQ by clicking this link. You have to register before you can post: click the REGISTER link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. View our Forum Privacy Policy.
  • Want to receive the latest contracting news and advice straight to your inbox? Sign up to the ContractorUK newsletter here. Every sign up will also be entered into a draw to WIN £100 Amazon vouchers!

You are not logged in or you do not have permission to access this page. This could be due to one of several reasons:

  • You are not logged in. If you are already registered, fill in the form below to log in, or follow the "Sign Up" link to register a new account.
  • You may not have sufficient privileges to access this page. Are you trying to edit someone else's post, access administrative features or some other privileged system?
  • If you are trying to post, the administrator may have disabled your account, or it may be awaiting activation.

Previously on "Contractor Limited Company and Divorce - Need advice"

Collapse

  • anonymous99
    replied
    Do something now if you already haven't.

    First of all, sorry your in this position as it stinks.

    It has been on the cards for a long time but now time has come up. We have been discussing what she wants out of the settlements and I never had any major issues with what she was demanding but lately she has been very agressive and everytime she has new thoughts from her web of advisors.
    Be very careful. She may be about to unleash all hell on you. Once the solicitors/legal team get involved you are in for a hard time.
    If you Ex is like mine she may be about to take you to the cleaners.

    You also have a very difficult setup.
    I would advise you to get advice ASAP.
    Work out what yuo have overall all it all up value wise, house, jewellery, investments, property, the lot. Divide by a ratio 50:50 if serious spousal maintenance to be given. If kids younger your looking at something like 70:30 to her.

    >Anyway here is the situation:
    >>1. We come from India.

    Has she filed for divorce?
    If not as you are from India maybe file for divorce there?
    They maybe more sympathetic to men.

    >> 2. Been married for 13 years and have two kids.

    How old are the kids. She will get the house and likely more than 50% as they are probably under 18. 70% : 30% to you something like that.

    >> 3. Few Properties in India, some in joint name and some in our individual names. All bought and paid by me.

    See post above re filing. if shes filed in this country it will *all* be in the pot. Does not matter whose name they are in.
    You may argue about properties bought before in your own name before the marriage. But seriously the judges dont really care. Its all both of yours as far as they are concerned.
    I came into a windfall during the proceedings after splitting and it was put in the pot.

    >> 4. Own a house here, owned by me and paid by me.

    She will get it on behalf of the kids as they are under 18.

    >> 5. She was a house wife and has been working for last 2 years and earns about 1000 a month. Not much of a pension.

    Get docs on it. You need to prove she can and will continue to work. And do it now before she is told to quit work. Your position should be "She can fend for herself and does not need maintenance as you own the house without mortgage?".

    >> 5. I have been contracting for just over 2 years via my limited company and take out min salary plus dividends just before hitting the max tax.

    It will all go in the pot. The judges don't understand these vehicles or at least mine did not. She took my day rate * 214 working days and took off the paye. That was it. No corp tax nothing taken into account. Be warned. Having the limited company and a good contract can be bad, very bad. I would suggest not renewing your contract and make it look like you are finding it hard to renew.
    Keep rejection letters. Make it look like finding a contract is very, very difficult. You will need it.

    >> 6. Finances apart, I want joint custody of the children with equal time with both parents. She agrees mostly but sometimes not.
    Custody is nothing to do with finances. The court will be only be concerned with money and assets. Kids is a separate agreement or contact order. It will be v expensive to go to court if she denies you access. Try to get an agreement on paper and get her to sign with someone else witnessing if you can.

    >>My questions are how the child benefits are calculated i.e. based on sal+dividends or the income of the business, which is about £110-120K per year?
    Does CSA considers the funds in the business as well for child maintenance?

    The child maintenance is based on your net earnings. So Sal & divvys. Although the CMS may only take the Sal into account. I would suggest though paying for your kids. You dont want your kids turning around in 5 years time saying your a sH&^. If looks like you are going to court, get the CMS involved. Get them to pick a child maintence figure. Do not allow the court to set it. They will do it on the basis on the lines below. You will end up over paying. And you cant get it reviewed for another year after the court order. If the CMS set the child maintenance before the court date, the court wont get involved in the figures for CM. Its more about protecting your assets at this stage. Pick your battles.


    >>Whether the final divorce settlement considers the funds in the business.
    Yes, its all game. They will take all your earnings as funds and capital in the account as an asset. Although if they take all your earnings as accessible they should not in theory touch the capital as is part of your income and would be double counting. That is the theory. However they did with me. I had 80k buffer in the bank and they split it too.

    >>I must admit, I have never taken any advice from the solicitors as I have always believed in a fair deal but seems to be upping her ante all the time.

    Take advice, Have a representation going into court, in form of a solicitor or barrister. Look at fixed fee barrister if you want to do a lot of the work on your own. Will save the solitors fees.
    Its expensive. We spent £120k fighting each other. Just because she could not accept anything. It was all about the fight.

    Do all you can to agree outside court. Save yourself the agro. Make her a serious offer with from fixed term maintenance topup until kids 18 or so.
    Do whatever you have to get a deal with a Section 25 clean break. Make that your target. Even if it hurts in the meantime. You will be thankful later.

    You have property.
    Maybe give her the house for the 'kids' sake.
    Maintenance to bring her up towards what she need so carry on until kids 18. so whats needed -£12k. So she needs £30k a year, give her £18k
    Set it all out on paper. Get solicitor to go over it and make it as a genuine offer, not "nonprejudicial" That way a judge will see in court you were trying to be fair.
    Make a serious offer, keep out of courts. You can/will be shafted if you dont.
    If you do get into court you need to fight like hell. You will need to seriously up the aunty on your position. I thought playing fair was enough.
    WRONG. I was screwed for playing fair. Don't get caught out like me and lots of others. I now work to pay by order of the court.
    Do the work now and save your self heartache and financial ruin.

    HTH.

    Fellow contractor/cash cow

    Leave a comment:


  • tarbera
    replied
    50-50, you will be lucky to end up with 80(her)-20(you) when her lawyers (you will be paying 80K for) get involved

    Leave a comment:


  • punjabilad
    replied
    Originally posted by MPwannadecentincome View Post
    2 months trading and already 70K in the bank? Wow!
    .
    Sorry that is for 2 years :-

    Many thanks for all your inputs/advice.

    Regards

    Leave a comment:


  • MPwannadecentincome
    replied
    As I said, my company has been trading for just over two months and have funds of the same range you have mentioned. However I did not have any break and infact I am at the same place where I started contracting. I also have to pay corp tax and will need dividends next year. I read somewhere about new trade aspect. Does it help in anyway? Does quitting the contract help in anyway? I would rather have some good time, relax, travel than paying her..Does that harm my case ?
    2 months trading and already 70K in the bank? Wow! Well if you can afford not to do the contract then upto you go ahead and give it up and enjoy the 70K however be careful her solicitor can use your earnings capacity as an argument to get a certain level of maintenance whether you are working or not. Better IMO to be in contract. I have no idea what new trade aspect is.

    Thanks for that piece of information. We have not even filed for divorce yet but I think I will file in a day or two. We are still living in the same house and are considering going for a mediator service. Is that advisable at this stage? Idea is that once we have an understanding, I will move out. At what stage, I should be registering the case with child maintenance?
    Mediator is a good idea in fact before any court case can be heard you have to have visited a mediator even if just to say you don't think using a mediator will work. Register the child maintenance as soon as you leave the house so plan your leaving accordingly.

    I have always been honest with her and have no issue declaring every single thing I own. Did you mean to say that even with me paying spousal maintenance, I would not be getting anywhere close to 50:50 or whether that was when I just want clean break? Do you think moving some funds from my business into the pension pot will make sense?
    With 2 kids you will not get 50:50 unless you pay substantial maintenance. Judge will secure needs for mother and kids as a priority above other things but leave you enough for your needs. If you can mediate and agree before it gets to a judge it is a lot better so don't get caught up too much in a few percentage points. Pension counts as I said before so whether you move it from company into pension is immaterial.

    She has said she will tell me tomorrow what she wants from me in terms of equity share and on a regular monthly payment. She has been told/advised that it is my daily rate that will be used to calculate my annual/monthly income to find out the child maintenance but it seems she is wrong there.
    The daily rate applies to the company's income so cannot be used to calculate your personal income. Your personal income is the salary and dividends you draw out of the company. Don't fool yourself into thinking to draw too little otherwise you will attract attention to the massively growing funds in your company at 35K per month.

    Now as I said, wikivorce is a better place for divorce topics.

    Leave a comment:


  • punjabilad
    replied
    Many thanks MPwannadecentincome, my sympathies with you as well as I was reading one of your thread and wish you luck!

    Originally posted by MPwannadecentincome View Post

    Anyway, a better place to raise this question is wikivorce.com a specialist forum with a discussion board for all things to do with divorce. It has Google search in the site and you can post some questions and people are helpful without the sarcasm and nasty comments.
    Thanks for this. This is where I am going next.

    Originally posted by MPwannadecentincome View Post

    In my case yes I had a Ltd Co but less than £70K in there which I argued was sufficient for paying corporation tax bill due and funding dividends needed to pay personal tax bills and for any benchtime, particularly as I was able to demonstrate how much bench time I had in the previous 2 years (total of 6 months at that time). So the funds in the company were not considered, however if there had been significantly more then I am sure it would have been different.
    As I said, my company has been trading for just over two months and have funds of the same range you have mentioned. However I did not have any break and infact I am at the same place where I started contracting. I also have to pay corp tax and will need dividends next year. I read somewhere about new trade aspect. Does it help in anyway? Does quitting the contract help in anyway? I would rather have some good time, relax, travel than paying her..Does that harm my case ?

    Originally posted by MPwannadecentincome View Post
    Child maintenance is at the end of the day based upon personal tax return gross income - in fact with the change in dividend tax from Apr 2016 and dividends are no longer grossed up this works in our favour. Go to child maintenance options website for guidance on how to calculate based on number of children etc etc and put in the gross weekly income. You can register with child maintenance service and they will look at your last tax return figures and calculate, however by default they seem to ignore dividends and get it wrong. Do not rely on that mistake as at some point they correct it. Better that you register the case with child maintenance before your Soon to be Ex (STBX) does it and she will tell them you earn more than you actually do. Note if you take out more dividends than normal then you will be liable for extra child maintenance if that goes higher that what was on the previous year's return.
    Thanks for that piece of information. We have not even filed for divorce yet but I think I will file in a day or two. We are still living in the same house and are considering going for a mediator service. Is that advisable at this stage? Idea is that once we have an understanding, I will move out. At what stage, I should be registering the case with child maintenance?

    Originally posted by MPwannadecentincome View Post
    Also if you want a clean break with just the child maintenance then expect to give up most of the equity, if you want to keep house equity or a share of the proceeds after sale then expect to pay spousal maintenance index linked for a very long time (in my case until death). With 2 kids involved you won't get anywhere near 50:50. You will have to declare every property, bank account and pension, yes the pension could be split. Get the solicitor to advise on how to value the pension's worth as it is not £ for £.

    Good luck.
    I have always been honest with her and have no issue declaring every single thing I own. Did you mean to say that even with me paying spousal maintenance, I would not be getting anywhere close to 50:50 or whether that was when I just want clean break? Do you think moving some funds from my business into the pension pot will make sense?

    She has said she will tell me tomorrow what she wants from me in terms of equity share and on a regular monthly payment. She has been told/advised that it is my daily rate that will be used to calculate my annual/monthly income to find out the child maintenance but it seems she is wrong there.

    Many thanks again to you.

    Regards,

    Leave a comment:


  • MPwannadecentincome
    replied
    Firstly my sympathies... I have been through this myself and in fact even though I have final settlement I am still facing court actions as my ex wants more money than I am paying in the court order and is threatening me with an other court order.

    Anyway, a better place to raise this question is wikivorce.com a specialist forum with a discussion board for all things to do with divorce. It has Google search in the site and you can post some questions and people are helpful without the sarcasm and nasty comments.

    In my case yes I had a Ltd Co but less than £70K in there which I argued was sufficient for paying corporation tax bill due and funding dividends needed to pay personal tax bills and for any benchtime, particularly as I was able to demonstrate how much bench time I had in the previous 2 years (total of 6 months at that time). So the funds in the company were not considered, however if there had been significantly more then I am sure it would have been different.

    Child maintenance is at the end of the day based upon personal tax return gross income - in fact with the change in dividend tax from Apr 2016 and dividends are no longer grossed up this works in our favour. Go to child maintenance options website for guidance on how to calculate based on number of children etc etc and put in the gross weekly income. You can register with child maintenance service and they will look at your last tax return figures and calculate, however by default they seem to ignore dividends and get it wrong. Do not rely on that mistake as at some point they correct it. Better that you register the case with child maintenance before your Soon to be Ex (STBX) does it and she will tell them you earn more than you actually do. Note if you take out more dividends than normal then you will be liable for extra child maintenance if that goes higher that what was on the previous year's return.

    Also if you want a clean break with just the child maintenance then expect to give up most of the equity, if you want to keep house equity or a share of the proceeds after sale then expect to pay spousal maintenance index linked for a very long time (in my case until death). With 2 kids involved you won't get anywhere near 50:50. You will have to declare every property, bank account and pension, yes the pension could be split. Get the solicitor to advise on how to value the pension's worth as it is not £ for £.

    Good luck.
    Last edited by MPwannadecentincome; 2 March 2017, 19:16.

    Leave a comment:


  • northernladuk
    replied
    Depends how good your solicitor is won't it? Assume the worst I think.

    Leave a comment:


  • punjabilad
    replied
    Thanks for the link, thats what I am going through right now.

    regarding settlement, will it make sense for me to move part of funds to my pension? Considering she does not have a pension of her own, my pension is also a potential target.

    Should I be looking at 50/50 or more like 70/30 for sharing the assets? I prefer a clean break, where I do not owe her anything apart from the child maintenance, plus I want the joint custody of the children.

    Leave a comment:


  • punjabilad
    replied
    Originally posted by northernladuk View Post
    I believe the company money will be made part of the settlement...

    But there is tons of discussion on various aspects of your situation in these threads...

    https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=di...hrome&ie=UTF-8
    Many thanks, thats what I googled and going through the threads.

    Since she does not have a pension of her own, I guess my pension pot (not very huge though) is also a potential target. Any point me taking out pension benfit? I guess that will only help if pension pot is not targetted, not sure if it is a good idea anyway. Also, the timing of transfer may create another set of problem, dont know!

    Leave a comment:


  • northernladuk
    replied
    I believe the company money will be made part of the settlement...

    But there is tons of discussion on various aspects of your situation in these threads...

    https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=di...hrome&ie=UTF-8

    Leave a comment:


  • Contractor Limited Company and Divorce - Need advice

    It has been on the cards for a long time but now time has come up. We have been discussing what she wants out of the settlements and I never had any major issues with what she was demanding but lately she has been very agressive and everytime she has new thoughts from her web of advisors. Anyway here is the situation:
    1. We come from India.
    2. Been married for 13 years and have two kids.
    3. Few Properties in India, some in joint name and some in our individual names. All bought and paid by me.
    4. Own a house here, owned by me and paid by me.
    5. She was a house wife and has been working for last 2 years and earns about 1000 a month. Not much of a pension.
    5. I have been contracting for just over 2 years via my limited company and take out min salary plus dividends just before hitting the max tax.
    6. Finances apart, I want joint custody of the children with equal time with both parents. She agrees mostly but sometimes not.

    My questions are how the child benefits are calculated i.e. based on sal+dividends or the income of the business, which is about £110-120K per year?
    Does CSA considers the funds in the business as well for child maintenance?
    Whether the final divorce settlement considers the funds in the business.

    I must admit, I have never taken any advice from the solicitors as I have always believed in a fair deal but seems to be upping her ante all the time.

    Any advice is appreciated.

Working...
X