Thursday Puzzle: Pondy's Party

[OwlHoot]

So if your name starts with 'M' you can bring something starting with 'S'.
If your name starts with 'S' you can bring something starting with 'J'

MF, can you bring Sausage Rolls, we're getting hungry.
SimonMac, can you bring a Jockstrap - Brillo lost at strip billiards and it's not a pretty sight.

I thought it was something like that, but what if your name starts with, um, (for example) 'O'?

[MarillionFan]

I thought it was something like that, but what if your name starts with, um, (for example) 'O'?

You can't come. It's an S&M party. :

[mudskipper]

I thought it was something like that, but what if your name starts with, um, (for example) 'O'?

Well, it's not V.

25 more posts should get you sorted.

[Pondlife]

can I bring lager or crisps

No you can't

Or more likely capital M's or J's. I'll bring the Marshmallow Jam then.

If you bring Jam, I'll bring Marshmallows

I thought it was something like that, but what if your name starts with, um, (for example) 'O'?

Since it's been the longest party in history and I really need you to all go home and get some sleep I'll give you a clue.

There is a reason that so many of you can bring Jam/Jagermeister/Jelly etc but it's not related to your name.

Obviously it has to be something that's known to everyone about you.

[mudskipper]

No you can't


If you bring Jam, I'll bring Marshmallows



Since it's been the longest party in history and I really need you to all go home and get some sleep I'll give you a clue.

There is a reason that so many of you can bring Jam/Jagermeister/Jelly etc but it's not related to your name.

Obviously it has to be something that's known to everyone about you.

Aha - I got it.

Bunk can bring the Olympic Torch.

[MarillionFan]

Groan.

Got it.

[Scoi]

It only took 20 pages of posts and finally got it. If only i could bring an anticlimax

[Pondlife]

It's got to the stage now where I'm too to give the answer.

It's based on a kids game.

WIS

[Bunk]

Aha - I got it.

Bunk can bring the Olympic Torch.

I could, but I'm not going to