- Joined
- Jul 6, 2005
- Messages
- 1,768
- Likes received
- 1
- Thanks received
- 1
I see no reason why they should not vote, apart from spite. They may be criminals and prisoners, but they are still citizens, not outlaws.Dundeegeorge said:What does the panel think about the idea of giving prisoners the vote?
(Hopefully there are no prisoners viewing this or SP will pull it (not helpfully move it to LR like other contentious postings not made by DG))
expat said:I see no reason why they should not vote, apart from spite. They may be criminals and prisoners, but they are still citizens, not outlaws.
Otherwise why restrict it to those serving a prison sentence? Take the vote from people who get fines. One speeding ticket and you're off the roll.
shaunbhoy said:Easy answer. If you do not abide by the rules of society, you forfeit some of the rights of said society. So whilst you are banged up at Her Majesty's Pleasure, bang goes your voting rights. Apply this to Custodial sentences only and it all becomes easy to police. Don't let the namby-pamby lefty lentil-munchers try and fudge the issue by carping on about speeding fines etc. Not the same thing at all.
Yes but there is an increasing trend towards keeping crims in the community by tagging etc. It is dependant on local magistrates as to who goes to the clink.shaunbhoy said:Easy answer. If you do not abide by the rules of society, you forfeit some of the rights of said society. So whilst you are banged up at Her Majesty's Pleasure, bang goes your voting rights. Apply this to Custodial sentences only and it all becomes easy to police. Don't let the namby-pamby lefty lentil-munchers try and fudge the issue by carping on about speeding fines etc. Not the same thing at all.
Wrong: I did not say that they were outlaws. In fact that is exactly the distinction I wanted to make. An outlaw is something quite differen from a lawbreaker.To BI or not to BI? said:But you just said they are outlaws. This means outside the law!!