why was I born so beautiful?

[TestMangler]

I suppose there is no debating with nationalists.

Poland found that out in 39.

No, read what I wrote again. I didn't ask for the spreadsheet. I asked if you remembered it.

So, I'll ask again, do you understand the origin of the 'Scottish Revenue' column and how it was derived ?

[minestrone]

I think this thread is done for me.

[TestMangler]

I think this thread is done for me.

So, you ask for a sensible debate and you refuse to continue at the asking of one simple question ?

Since saying you'd happily debate you've posted the same picture of Alex Salmond, compared Scots voting SNP with the Nazis and now you're off in a huff. You are, I must admit, a master debater.

[minestrone]

I will happily equate segments of Scottish nationalism to Socialist nationalism seen in Germany in 33.

[minestrone]

Flag waving.

[TestMangler]

I will happily equate segments of Scottish nationalism to Socialist nationalism seen in Germany in 33.

But not Irish Nationalism though. Happy to see kids killed in shopping centre bombings, but abhor people voting for the SNP. OK, thanks for your input, it's been interesting.

[TestMangler]

Flag waving.

None of that here, of course.

[minestrone]

arm wrestle.

[Batcher]

I actually think the north sea oil revenue is the most indicative point of the image.

The UK has made feck all from the stuff.

Now you and you SNP followers might like to thin there is money to be made from the stuff but really you can see Scotland has made more from the financial arrangements within London than Scotland has made from Scotland.

HTH

That is the real tragedy. We could have an oil fund that is helping us through these tough times but the money made from the oil was pissed up against the wall.

Have you ever read the McCrone Report that was buried for 30 years because the UK government knew it would lead to Scottish independence?

[EternalOptimist]

That is the real tragedy. We could have an oil fund that is helping us through these tough times but the money made from the oil was pissed up against the wall.

Have you ever read the McCrone Report that was buried for 30 years because the UK government knew it would lead to Scottish independence?

It wasn't so long ago that Salmon was snogging the oil industry to get them to stick with Grangemouth. Now the jocks have a moratorium on shale fracking.

So what is it , haggis munchers ? Do you want Grangemouth, jobs and wealth or not ?