why was I born so beautiful?

[EternalOptimist]

If this is going to be you're tact addressing my points on with me then I can tell .......

tack

[TestMangler]

So tell me what you want to talk about, let's go...

I can debate and talk about Scottish nationalism...

You first...

OK, your other picture (the income with and without oil income that you keep posting) that shows an 80 billion deficit over 30 odd years, less that the UK deficit for this year by the way, but lets leave that to one side for the moment.

I asked you twice when you posted it during the referendum campaign if you knew the origin of the figures for 'Scottish income' and you ignored it, so I'll ask you again. did you read the guidance notes or do you know how the figures were actually determined, given that there is no Scottish only taxation.

[minestrone]

What this...

[EternalOptimist]

The carnage in the Scottish oil industry is a true tragedy , but credit to Salmon, he was the only politician to see it coming and make the accurate predictions

and my @rse is a cream bun

[minestrone]

I actually think the north sea oil revenue is the most indicative point of the image.

The UK has made feck all from the stuff.

Now you and you SNP followers might like to thin there is money to be made from the stuff but really you can see Scotland has made more from the financial arrangements within London than Scotland has made from Scotland.

HTH

[minestrone]

[TestMangler]

See, you're off being a dick, again.

You said you wanted to discuss it and I asked you a question. Do you want a sensible discussion or do you want to act like a dick. Your choice ?

Also note, the question I asked you had nothing to do with oil revenue, but off you went again....

[minestrone]

You asked to see the spreadsheet then you complain when you see the spreadsheet.

I don't think I'm being a dick.

[TestMangler]

You asked to see the spreadsheet then you complain when you see the spreadsheet.

I don't think I'm being a dick.

No, read what I wrote again. I didn't ask for the spreadsheet. I asked if you remembered it.

So, I'll ask again, do you understand the origin of the 'Scottish Revenue' column and how it was derived ?

[minestrone]

I suppose there is no debating with nationalists.

Poland found that out in 39.