BN66 - Round 2 (Court of Appeal)

[Emigre]

I would like to correct something I've stated previously.

Apparently Lord Justice Mummery, who was one the judges who heard our case, is sitting through the court recess so there is a chance we could get a decision over the summer.

I'm not holding my breath mind you.

Ultimately isn't it the case that the senior LJ on the bench hands down the decision? In order for Mummery to hand down the decision wouldn't he need to be that person AND for the two other LJs to have opined before the recess?

Not holding my breath either!

[hmrcarethieves]

Time machine at work again...

Gaines-Cooper case gets Supreme Court hearing

[DonkeyRhubarb]

Ultimately isn't it the case that the senior LJ on the bench hands down the decision? In order for Mummery to hand down the decision wouldn't he need to be that person AND for the two other LJs to have opined before the recess?

Mummery is the most senior of the 3 LJs so it is theoretically possible.

However, personally I think it's unlikely we'll get a decision until the tail end of the year.

[DonkeyRhubarb]

Fasten your seatbelts folks!!!

Judgment day is upon us.

Court of Appeal Civil Division

NOTICE
Take notice that on MONDAY, 25 JULY, 2011 in COURT 70, at 10 O'CLOCK, Judgment will be given in the following.
APPEALS
From The Queen's Bench Division
(Administrative Court and Divisional Court)
FINAL DECISIONS
C1/2010/0360 The Queen on the application of Huitson -v- Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs.
C1/2009/1224 Queen on the Application of Shiner & anr -v- Commissioners of Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs.

[Vallah]

Judgment day is upon us.

Court of Appeal Civil Division

NOTICE
Take notice that on MONDAY, 25 JULY, 2011 in COURT 70, at 10 O'CLOCK, Judgment will be given in the following.
APPEALS
From The Queen's Bench Division
(Administrative Court and Divisional Court)
FINAL DECISIONS
C1/2010/0360 The Queen on the application of Huitson -v- Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs.
C1/2009/1224 Queen on the Application of Shiner & anr -v- Commissioners of Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs.

Bloody hell!

Good luck.

[Emigre]

Judgment day is upon us.

Court of Appeal Civil Division

NOTICE
Take notice that on MONDAY, 25 JULY, 2011 in COURT 70, at 10 O'CLOCK, Judgment will be given in the following.
APPEALS
From The Queen's Bench Division
(Administrative Court and Divisional Court)
FINAL DECISIONS
C1/2010/0360 The Queen on the application of Huitson -v- Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs.
C1/2009/1224 Queen on the Application of Shiner & anr -v- Commissioners of Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs.

Its going to be a long week! And if it goes our way it will be a very long week for HMRC next week.

[Buzby]

oh my god

Judgment day is upon us.

Court of Appeal Civil Division

NOTICE
Take notice that on MONDAY, 25 JULY, 2011 in COURT 70, at 10 O'CLOCK, Judgment will be given in the following.
APPEALS
From The Queen's Bench Division
(Administrative Court and Divisional Court)
FINAL DECISIONS
C1/2010/0360 The Queen on the application of Huitson -v- Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs.
C1/2009/1224 Queen on the Application of Shiner & anr -v- Commissioners of Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs.

looks like I picked the wrong week to try and cut down on wine!

[smalldog]

Judgment day is upon us.

Court of Appeal Civil Division

NOTICE
Take notice that on MONDAY, 25 JULY, 2011 in COURT 70, at 10 O'CLOCK, Judgment will be given in the following.
APPEALS
From The Queen's Bench Division
(Administrative Court and Divisional Court)
FINAL DECISIONS
C1/2010/0360 The Queen on the application of Huitson -v- Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs.
C1/2009/1224 Queen on the Application of Shiner & anr -v- Commissioners of Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs.

first day of my holiday brilliant timing, nothing like a bit of stress when you are trying to relax on holiday!!!!

[SantaClaus]

first day of my holiday brilliant timing, nothing like a bit of stress when you are trying to relax on holiday!!!!

Of course, there's always the option of staying there.

I hear Panama is quite nice this time of year.

[patbikeruk]

OMG - Do we know what happens next? Win or lose??

Do we know where we go next if we lose?

Does it just go away if we win?

I know it is not that simple but any ideas?