Are blanket determinations really unlawful?

[SimonMac]

Role-based blanket IR35 assessments are unlawful and highly risky

However the problem is that you won't get anyone making blanket determinations, they will just ban PSC's

[ladymuck]

Nope.


Illegal means that it is forbidden by a law that has been passed.
Unlawful means that it is not authorised by law because no such law has been passed.

IANAL

That's why I started the sentence with "to me", knowing full well that's not the actual way the term should be interpreted.

But thanks for mansplaining and really helping the discussion.

[eatenrifles]

However the problem is that you won't get anyone making blanket determinations, they will just ban PSC's

Tell that to my client. They blanket assessed everyone as inside. The agencies will still pay net to Ltd Co if you wish, so PSCs are still allowed.