PM Questions

[The Master]

Yes.

I do.

> cough cough <

[AlfredJPruffock]

Apparently Andrew has just been detained under the Terrorist Act .

[hyperD]

Unless you happen to be Andrew Robathan (Tory MP) who asked:

"Will the Prime Minister tell the House on how many occasions he has started an investigation under his ministerial code, and whether he thinks it appropriate that his Deputy Prime Minister should stay with an American business man—"

and Michael Martin (Speaker) replies:

"Order. This matter has been put before the Parliamentary Commissioner, and there will be no more discussion about it until the Parliamentary Commissioner has dealt with it."

[The Lone Gunman]

A friend of mine who, until recently was a senior civil servant told me that when the 'formal' questions are received (not just for PMQ's but for any minister), vast numbers of hours are expended by the minister's staff in trying to anticipate and concoct answers to any supplementary question which might arise.

If a supplementary for which a minister does not have a script is asked, then this is a major black mark for the people in his department.

For most ministers the supplementary questions have to be related to the subject of the first question and for the portfolio. For PMQs they can be entirely random.

[Phoenix]

A friend of mine who, until recently was a senior civil servant told me that when the 'formal' questions are received (not just for PMQ's but for any minister), vast numbers of hours are expended by the minister's staff in trying to anticipate and concoct answers to any supplementary question which might arise.

If a supplementary for which a minister does not have a script is asked, then this is a major black mark for the people in his department.

Which proves.... who really runs the country.

[The Lone Gunman]

This is the explanation I heard more than once, but it does not apply to the very very first question he gets - it seems always to be on his engagements on that day: the following proper questions are known to PM, apart from supplementary question to those proper question, but the very first question seems to be tradition of some kind as the answer to it is always the same.

Sorry, forgot to cover that bit. The first question is staged. Asking him about his diary, he then says it is published or can be seen or something. This then allows him to give the standard "I refer my honourable friend to the answer I gave earlier". It saves a lot of messing about with the questions.

[FrankScribe]

A friend of mine who, until recently was a senior civil servant told me that when the 'formal' questions are received (not just for PMQ's but for any minister), vast numbers of hours are expended by the minister's staff in trying to anticipate and concoct answers to any supplementary question which might arise.

If a supplementary for which a minister does not have a script is asked, then this is a major black mark for the people in his department.

[Phoenix]

Politicians....Straight questions/answers?
Not on your life !

[AtW]

I hope that reads OK and is a decent explanation.

This is the explanation I heard more than once, but it does not apply to the very very first question he gets - it seems always to be on his engagements on that day: the following proper questions are known to PM, apart from supplementary question to those proper question, but the very first question seems to be tradition of some kind as the answer to it is always the same.

[The Lone Gunman]

So all questions during PM time are actually supplementary to that first traditionary question about what he does that day?

Generally yes. Its tradition. For PMQs (I may be slightly off on this). All original questions have to be submitted prior to save time. The questioner is then allowed a splementary question.
To avoid giving the PM time to prepare the first questions are usualy about his diary and to avoid giving repetetive answers the PM refers to the answer he gave earlier.
The second question is the sprung and the opposition hope to trip up the PM by catching him unprepared.

I hope that reads OK and is a decent explanation.

[AtW]

So all questions during PM time are actually supplementary to that first traditionary question about what he does that day?

[AtW]

Why the first question always seems to be about PMs engagements on that day, that he does not seem to answer straight anyway?