Reply to: Team GB first gold medal

[Paddy]

oh yes, they're rowing

hadn't noticed...

Why are they rowing? Can't they get on with each other?

[Mich the Tester]

Maybe that didn't help, I don't know what Chambers was like, but if he never played the game when younger I'd have been shocked if he became good enough to turn professional after starting in his mid-twenties.

While he was being trained up at Castleford and on their payroll, having pissed off a lot of young players who were more talented, he held a press conference to announce he wanted to compete in the Oympics again; not exactly the commitment that's expected of rugby players in either code.

[Doggy Styles]

He was certainly more succesful; it might also have something to do with attitude. As in; Nigel Walker wasn't a self obsessed arrogant **** who thought he knew it all.

Maybe that didn't help, I don't know what Chambers was like, but if he never played the game when younger I'd have been shocked if he became good enough to turn professional after starting in his mid-twenties.

[TimberWolf]

Well done, the British female coxless pair have done us proud. First camel toe of the 2012 Olympics and a gold medal to boot.

[Mich the Tester]

Indeed it didn't.

Nigel Walker switched from hurdles to Rugby Union, but he'd played rugby when he was younger so he had the skills. Even played for Wales IIRC.

He was certainly more succesful; it might also have something to do with attitude. As in; Nigel Walker wasn't a self obsessed arrogant **** who thought he knew it all.

[Doggy Styles]

Dwain Chambers tried to switch to rugby league and it didn't go well.

Indeed it didn't.

Nigel Walker switched from hurdles to Rugby Union, but he'd played rugby when he was younger so he had the skills. Even played for Wales IIRC.

[Mich the Tester]

I think that learning the techniques of how to row well (or how to run well/cycle well) are easier than learning the techniques for racket sports/football etc simply due to the hand/eye co-ordination needed, the understanding of the game so you have an 'extra 5 yards in your head' etc

I think a few years back a good sprinter (sub 10.20 100 meters) tried to switch to playing football - based on the fact his speed would be enough.... he bombed if I recall.

Dwain Chambers tried to switch to rugby league and it didn't go well.

[original PM]

are you serious?

I probably would have thought so before the years of going to Regattas, there is a tremendous amount of skill and tactics in rowing, coupled with, yes, enormous physical fitness

I think that learning the techniques of how to row well (or how to run well/cycle well) are easier than learning the techniques for racket sports/football etc simply due to the hand/eye co-ordination needed, the understanding of the game so you have an 'extra 5 yards in your head' etc

I think a few years back a good sprinter (sub 10.20 100 meters) tried to switch to playing football - based on the fact his speed would be enough.... he bombed if I recall.

[Mich the Tester]

are you serious?

I probably would have thought so before the years of going to Regattas, there is a tremendous amount of skill and tactics in rowing, coupled with, yes, enormous physical fitness

Indeed, but it's a skill that can be learned in a few years, as opposed to ball skills that need many years of practice; not saying rowing to hockey is impossible, just less likely than the other way around. Add to that, physical prowess is good in hockey, but won't win against great skill, whereas a less skilled rower might win against a physically weaker but skilled rower.

[Bacchus]

On a serious note, most good sportspeople can switch from one sport to another and do well, especially when they switch to a sport where the physical fitness/strength element is greater than the skill element; not wishing to disparage here of course, but switching from say rowing to hockey would be more difficult then the other way around. Rowing's probably much more hard work though. Rebecca Romero switched from rowing to cycling with great success, and I believe a number of the best NZ track cyclists played a high standard of rugby before switching to the bike.

are you serious?

I probably would have thought so before the years of going to Regattas, there is a tremendous amount of skill and tactics in rowing, coupled with, yes, enormous physical fitness

[Mich the Tester]

Bugger me,...

careful mate, Old Greg's on the forum today.

[Doggy Styles]

Bugger me, now the men's eight have got a bronze.

[SimonMac]

just before she took up water sports?

No she was into water sports before the accident

[Mich the Tester]

Its very impressive seeing as Heather is a Captain in the Royal Artillery and nearly lost her arm in a live fire exercise

just before she took up water sports?

[Mich the Tester]

Apparently they didn't even row until a few years ago, anyone can do it, Im going to go for the 100m in 2016.....

On a serious note, most good sportspeople can switch from one sport to another and do well, especially when they switch to a sport where the physical fitness/strength element is greater than the skill element; not wishing to disparage here of course, but switching from say rowing to hockey would be more difficult then the other way around. Rowing's probably much more hard work though. Rebecca Romero switched from rowing to cycling with great success, and I believe a number of the best NZ track cyclists played a high standard of rugby before switching to the bike.