Reply to: When CUK descends into pack mentality

[realityhack]

Oh my - they grow up so fast!

I can post something silly as an antidote to that if you like.

Please see 90% of my previous posts for examples.

[SandyDown]

What's done is done - let's move on.

If CD wants to come back it would be fairly easy for him to do - and then we can have this adventure all over again, learning from our previous mistakes. Remember, he asked to be removed from this board.

Pack mentality - the consequences distasteful for some in this case - is a natural human trait and reflects the sentiment towards CD's contributions to the board.

The mods have to keep the reputational risk of unchallenged racism on this board in mind, and acted appropriately in this case IMHO.

Views are merely views, you can't please everyone, and it's not about political correctness. In this case a user was being consistently disruptive, abusive and offensive, others have been banned for less.

Think about the appropriate behaviour for this forum and the margin of tolerance we have to ramble on about anything under the sun - I think this is great if we do it respectfully, with the good attitude most demonstrate - even while insulting each other tongue-in-cheek - even when passionate about issues such as CSA/access or freedom of speech.

Anyone can write about anything they please, but if I came to this board for the first time as a contractor or journo my opinion of CUK would be negatively impacted if I saw unchallenged threads about racism, national socialism, smut, flaming or otherwise - it would give me the impression that we all implicitly endorse such behaviour.

We did challenge CD - and it became tiring after a while because he kept banging away at the same drum and refusing to engage with the counter-arguments - a typical political tactic to batter opposition into submission. Eventually we would have offered only token resistance to his views or ignored him altogether, creating the impression above.

My tuppence.

Oh my - they grow up so fast!

[richard-af]

My tuppence.

Cheapskate!

[realityhack]

What's done is done - let's move on.

If CD wants to come back it would be fairly easy for him to do - and then we can have this adventure all over again, learning from our previous mistakes. Remember, he asked to be removed from this board.

Pack mentality - the consequences distasteful for some in this case - is a natural human trait and reflects the sentiment towards CD's contributions to the board.

The mods have to keep the reputational risk of unchallenged racism on this board in mind, and acted appropriately in this case IMHO.

Views are merely views, you can't please everyone, and it's not about political correctness. In this case a user was being consistently disruptive, abusive and offensive, others have been banned for less.

Think about the appropriate behaviour for this forum and the margin of tolerance we have to ramble on about anything under the sun - I think this is great if we do it respectfully, with the good attitude most demonstrate - even while insulting each other tongue-in-cheek - even when passionate about issues such as CSA/access or freedom of speech.

Anyone can write about anything they please, but if I came to this board for the first time as a contractor or journo my opinion of CUK would be negatively impacted if I saw unchallenged threads about racism, national socialism, smut, flaming or otherwise - it would give me the impression that we all implicitly endorse such behaviour.

We did challenge CD - and it became tiring after a while because he kept banging away at the same drum and refusing to engage with the counter-arguments - a typical political tactic to batter opposition into submission. Eventually we would have offered only token resistance to his views or ignored him altogether, creating the impression above.

My tuppence.

[Troll]

The poll option was biased.

Also the poll duration was very short... I believe the term is "indecent haste"

[wendigo100]

Maybe a public hanging was not the best way to do it in hindsight but if you had all voted for him to stay instead of a 4 - 1 vote to ban him then maybe the outcome would have been different. His blood is on your hands too.

The poll option was biased.

[richard-af]

"free speech includes not only the inoffensive but the irritating, the contentious, the eccentric, the heretical, the unwelcome and the provocative provided it does not tend to provoke violence. Freedom only to speak inoffensively is not worth having." -- Lord Justice Sedley, Redmond-Bate v BPP 1999.

Then he won't mind me saying "Feck off, your Honour.", will he?

[Methuselah]

...We are extremely tolerant on this board, just not of racism - even at its lowest level. As Sasguru said he did post some terrible crap here and as far as I am concerned he got what he deserved. In fact he lasted a lot longer than he should done really.

"free speech includes not only the inoffensive but the irritating, the contentious, the eccentric, the heretical, the unwelcome and the provocative provided it does not tend to provoke violence. Freedom only to speak inoffensively is not worth having." -- Lord Justice Sedley, Redmond-Bate v BPP 1999.

[Diver]

We must be in the hit list top ten by now
But only for posting nonsensical cr@p and thread diverts.

Do they ban for that?

If they ban me I'm coming back as el doodler

[OwlHoot]

btw: does anyone remember what did Hell. something and Hull say to get banned??

Hull Hull & Halifax, and a few other names. More of a bungey (sp?) poster than a regular.

I found him pretty funny - Livened up a few dull days on the board anyway.

[Troll]

Oh!
Someone Trolling again

Just looking after your interests old friend

[Diver]

Oh!
Someone Trolling again

[Troll]

I take the hint

Yes old chap... please be carefull

[Churchill]

The Cat...hahahahahahaha. Next we will have Churchill signing his with "The Dog"...

No you 'kin won't!!!

[SandyDown]

up to my ears [as usual] but no, think more sunset song and robert's tearful words to chrissie when he realises how much he has let her down.

Huh? what kind of shows to you see?

Let me guess is this from : "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest"

(only joking of course, seriously which chrissie we are talking about?)