Reply to: Owen Smith

[LondonManc]

The MPs are the ones that the people elected. The party elected Corbyn but obviously anyone who would join a political party is not representative of the typical voter, so really this whole thing is a battle of more extreme party members vs. the people.

All of this would be fine if we were talking about UKIP, or the Greens, or anybody else on the sidelines but we need Labour to form a viable opposition and with Corbyn the signs are that the Tories will go unopposed for a decade. Which is probably why so many Tories were happy to join Labour and vote for him.

We don't need Labour in power; we need a decent Labour opposition to keep a Tory government on their toes. Corbyn would be capable of that if the party backed him. Support for Corbyn has been growing; a mass revolt if he's voted out by MPs could see a splinter of Labour.

[VectraMan]

Neither did I but I'm not a member of the Labour Party and believe that each party should sort themselves out and establish their leader, not to then have that decision reversed by the champagne socialists whose gravy train Mr Corbyn will no doubt derail should he be given the chance. I admire the bloke, albeit I don't necessarily agree with him on many things.

The MPs are the ones that the people elected. The party elected Corbyn but obviously anyone who would join a political party is not representative of the typical voter, so really this whole thing is a battle of more extreme party members vs. the people.

All of this would be fine if we were talking about UKIP, or the Greens, or anybody else on the sidelines but we need Labour to form a viable opposition and with Corbyn the signs are that the Tories will go unopposed for a decade. Which is probably why so many Tories were happy to join Labour and vote for him.

[LondonManc]

Which voters? I didn't get to vote on the leader of the opposition.

Neither did I but I'm not a member of the Labour Party and believe that each party should sort themselves out and establish their leader, not to then have that decision reversed by the champagne socialists whose gravy train Mr Corbyn will no doubt derail should he be given the chance. I admire the bloke, albeit I don't necessarily agree with him on many things.

[VectraMan]

So, 208 Labour MPs are of the mind that they can pick a more electable candidate than the one that the voters actually wanted? Certainly explains the way the country has gone over the last couple of decades.

Which voters? I didn't get to vote on the leader of the opposition.

[LondonManc]

So, 208 Labour MPs are of the mind that they can pick a more electable candidate than the one that the voters actually wanted? Certainly explains the way the country has gone over the last couple of decades.

[shaunbhoy]

Someone told him that a vacuum was forming at the top of the Labour Party. They neglected to tell him that this vacuum comprised the space between the ears of Corbyn, Eagle, and Smith.

[barrydidit]

Spot on. He's a hypocrite lefty. Corbyn is full blown but at least he believes what he says. Most of the lefties have millions stashed away and live in bloody big houses they inherited.

Cheers, that'll save me wasting time on him. I'd assumed before reading this thread he was another moderate who was going to split the vote and guarantee Corbyn's continuity. Even so, he's doomed to fail of course, being more left (red) is the key in these situations. As Mao's cultural revolution taught us

The reddest, reddest, red sun in our heart, Chairman Mao, and us together

[GB9]

Because I can't be arsed to research this chunt, can someone confirm my suspicion that he's running with the 'lefty looney who is not not quite as lefty looney as Corbyn' card?

Spot on. He's a hypocrite lefty. Corbyn is full blown but at least he believes what he says. Most of the lefties have millions stashed away and live in bloody big houses they inherited.

[barrydidit]

Because I can't be arsed to research this chunt, can someone confirm my suspicion that he's running with the 'lefty looney who is not not quite as lefty looney as Corbyn' card?

[GB9]

Apparently Comrade Smith is to introduce an annual 10% levy on all BTL income.

[AtW]

Glad to be of service but the squirrels stay well outside.

If they are a bit hungry they may be encouraged to eat Churchill and pals.

Deal!

[SueEllen]

Or run up his trousers and nibble his nuts.

Good to see you survived your "relaxing" experience.

[mudskipper]

Glad to be of service but the squirrels stay well outside.

If they are a bit hungry they may be encouraged to eat Churchill and pals.

Or run up his trousers and nibble his nuts.

[SueEllen]

I was planning to hide in her house

Glad to be of service but the squirrels stay well outside.

If they are a bit hungry they may be encouraged to eat Churchill and pals.

[AtW]

So, you always were a "red".

Come the Revolution mate, you're 2nd or 3rd against the wall.

I'll take my chances...