Reply to: Brexit: the last ditch

[Old Greg]

Hypothetical questions are not relevant until they have facts to back them up in which case they are no longer hypothetical. I think on Thursday you will have the answer to your question which is why the major parties are running scared.

Brain the size of a planet and I still have to communicate with morons

Too scared. Fair enough. But happy to talk about hypothetical outcomes on Thursday.

[Yorkie62]

There may be one, so it is relevant. Or are you too scared to answer a hypothetical question?

Hypothetical questions are not relevant until they have facts to back them up in which case they are no longer hypothetical. I think on Thursday you will have the answer to your question which is why the major parties are running scared.

Brain the size of a planet and I still have to communicate with morons

[Old Greg]

But there isn't a 2nd referendum and until there is one you question like you is irrelevant.

Brain the size of a planet and I still have to communicate with morons

There may be one, so it is relevant. Or are you too scared to answer a hypothetical question?

[Yorkie62]

What if there were a Remain result of a second referendum, which was enacted by democratically elected MPs? Which referendum result shoud be honoured then?

But there isn't a 2nd referendum and until there is one you question like you is irrelevant.

Brain the size of a planet and I still have to communicate with morons

[BrilloPad]

I accept your concession of defeat.

Was that addressed to me personally or the whole of the UK on Brexit?

[Old Greg]

Who appointed you Paxman?

Anyway, my response was better than you gave to Churchill earlier.

I accept your concession of defeat.

[BrilloPad]

Do you have an answer to my question?

Who appointed you Paxman?

Anyway, my response was better than you gave to Churchill earlier.

[Old Greg]

I have no objection to a 2nd referendum. In about 40 years time.

But asking people to vote until they give the right result sends the wrong message.

Do you have an answer to my question?

[BrilloPad]

What if there were a Remain result of a second referendum, which was enacted by democratically elected MPs? Which referendum result shoud be honoured then?

I have no objection to a 2nd referendum. In about 40 years time.

But asking people to vote until they give the right result sends the wrong message.

[Old Greg]

The will of the people was a vote to leave therefore any implementation that does not deliver a leave result must be undemocratic. It is very black and white. No shades of grey required

Brain the size of a planet and I still have to communicate with morons

What if there were a Remain result of a second referendum, which was enacted by democratically elected MPs? Which referendum result shoud be honoured then?

[Yorkie62]

The suggestion does not go against the will of the people. The suggestion makes a statement of fact - it is a way forward. It may be a democratic way forward, or an undemocratic way forward, or it may be that there are shades of grey.

HTH
BIDI

The will of the people was a vote to leave therefore any implementation that does not deliver a leave result must be undemocratic. It is very black and white. No shades of grey required

Brain the size of a planet and I still have to communicate with morons

[Old Greg]

Suggestion the no Brexit is a way forward goes against the democratic will of the people as voiced at the referendum and is therefore against the democratic will of the people. Simples.

Brain the size of a planet and I still have to communicate with morons

The suggestion does not go against the will of the people. The suggestion makes a statement of fact - it is a way forward. It may be a democratic way forward, or an undemocratic way forward, or it may be that there are shades of grey.

HTH
BIDI

[Yorkie62]

That is untrue and an illogical conclusion.

Suggestion the no Brexit is a way forward goes against the democratic will of the people as voiced at the referendum and is therefore against the democratic will of the people. Simples.

Brain the size of a planet and I still have to communicate with morons

[Old Greg]

So you don't support democracy then, re: referendum.

Brain the size of a planet and I still have to communicate with morons

That is untrue and an illogical conclusion.

[Yorkie62]

Agree re WA. But No deal is not the only way forward. No Brexit is also a way forward.

So you don't support democracy then, re: referendum.

Brain the size of a planet and I still have to communicate with morons