What I forgot to include in my last post was that 30 years ago, contractors working for agencies were allowed to be sole traders. But too many never declared their income.
So they made the Agencies responsible for "employing" of the contractors. They understandably did not want to do this, so they came up with the Ltd Company idea. This worked reasonably well until the HMRC put in the new computer systems to cope with SA etc...........
- Visitors can check out the Forum FAQ by clicking this link. You have to register before you can post: click the REGISTER link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. View our Forum Privacy Policy.
- Want to receive the latest contracting news and advice straight to your inbox? Sign up to the ContractorUK newsletter here. Every sign up will also be entered into a draw to WIN £100 Amazon vouchers!
Reply to: Is the death knell ringing for IR35
Collapse
You are not logged in or you do not have permission to access this page. This could be due to one of several reasons:
- You are not logged in. If you are already registered, fill in the form below to log in, or follow the "Sign Up" link to register a new account.
- You may not have sufficient privileges to access this page. Are you trying to edit someone else's post, access administrative features or some other privileged system?
- If you are trying to post, the administrator may have disabled your account, or it may be awaiting activation.
Logging in...
Previously on "Is the death knell ringing for IR35"
Collapse
-
Originally posted by DonkeyRhubarb View PostThis may be a really daft question, but why can't contractors operate as sole traders? I believe that Class 2 & 4 NIC is similar to employees NIC, so this would put us on a par with employees.
When I first started doing s/e accounts and tax work, the HMRC had just done the same to the Newspaper industry. I had a client who used to do sub-editing for newspapers (Employee), as well as received payment for freelanced writing. Each year she had up to 15 sub editor posts (changing constantly), year 2 the HMRC confirmed it should all be treated as s/e income in future.
A couple of years later it was s/e teachers - now they are all employees unless they are running a Ltd company and employ others. Then s/e office cleaners. Unless they had several contracts and did s/e accounts they had to be treated as employees. Each case of s/e had to be agreed in writing with HMRC in advance.
The HMRC prefer everyone to be an employee, that way they don't have to rely on people to be honest.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by gingerjedi View PostI would, I just don't see why I should pay significantly more than an employee who has a pension, holidays, sickness etc. There has to some sort of payoff for the flexibility contractors provide.
If HMRC want to tax me as an employee and an employer then HMRC should provide me with these perks.
If you (the employer) don't get a sufficiently higher rate to cover that, then the client is shafting HMRC by finding a way out of paying NICs, and using you as a mug in that tax fraud.
If you (the employer) do get a sufficiently high rate to cover it, but you would rather keep the money, then you are just greedy enough to want to gain by tax fraud.
... and if you do not want to treat yourself as an employee an an employer, get a job.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by helen7 View PostYou are only looking at court case figures. won vs lost.
How many people do you think own up and are actually paying in?
Not a problem though. Seems "British" employers can fly in foreign workers with near impunity. Despite this government's purported hatred of local contractors, it seems to have no qualms allowing employers to fly people in who, it turns out, are often as expensive AND less well qualified than the now-unemployed, local talent.
I don't see things getting better, only worse. This current economic mess will take a decade or two to lessen. Unemployment is rising fast, companies are shutting, those that have made losses (banks for example) can offset them for years to come....meanwhile, there are all those top bankers' bonuses you and I have to pay for.
And for those in jobs, you'll be paying via higher taxes, and no doubt an IR35++ law to come into effect, if indeed they don't retrospectively change the law as they did with BN66.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by DonkeyRhubarb View PostThis may be a really daft question, but why can't contractors operate as sole traders? I believe that Class 2 & 4 NIC is similar to employees NIC, so this would put us on a par with employees.
Hence agents/clientco's refuse to business with us as sole traders.
But if you can find a mug of a client prepared to go the sole trader route, then go for it.
Leave a comment:
-
Sole trader?
Originally posted by gingerjedi View PostI would, I just don't see why I should pay significantly more than an employee who has a pension, holidays, sickness etc. There has to some sort of payoff for the flexibility contractors provide.
If HMRC want to tax me as an employee and an employer then HMRC should provide me with these perks.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by DonkeyRhubarb View PostAnyway, out of interest would people accept being under PAYE if you didn't have to pay employers NI? If I'm right, that would give an extra 12% net.
But I do begrudge having to pay the same tax twice - especially when I don't get any of the benefits of being an employee.
It won't happen though. It will open up a separate loophole to avoid employers NI.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by DonkeyRhubarb View PostI am no longer contracting anymore, and haven't run a company for a long time. My last contract was through an IoM scheme (no comments please).
Anyway, out of interest would people accept being under PAYE if you didn't have to pay employers NI? If I'm right, that would give an extra 12% net.
I'm not saying it would even be possible to frame legislation to exclude certain groups from Employers NI, but if it were then it could be a reasonable compromise.
If HMRC want to tax me as an employee and an employer then HMRC should provide me with these perks.
Leave a comment:
-
Exempt from Employers NI?
I am no longer contracting anymore, and haven't run a company for a long time. My last contract was through an IoM scheme (no comments please).
Anyway, out of interest would people accept being under PAYE if you didn't have to pay employers NI? If I'm right, that would give an extra 12% net.
I'm not saying it would even be possible to frame legislation to exclude certain groups from Employers NI, but if it were then it could be a reasonable compromise.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by Jubber View PostWell ...... this has been much discussed already and this is part of the problem with IR35 - who knows? I had a PAYE (IR35) review a few years back and it was fine. The fear of this stuff is crazy.
I run my business they way I feel is correct. Have I been negligent doing so? No - my contracts are outside of IR35 to the best of my knowledge and to the knowledge of other external professional (lol) advisors.
(IMHO) - If the tax man decides otherwise I suppose a judge would have to decide and Hector would have to prove that I acted negligently as a director. Much harder to prove than just force his opinion on me about a contract or two.
(IMHO) - Hector is trying to collect this revenue by fear and slight of hand, like a lot of the tactics with dubious taxation.
By the way - what has happened in the high profile cases recently Dragonfly and Kingfisher etc?
Consider yourself lucky! Whilst working for Capgemini on the HMRC account, I showed my contract to 2 inspectors in 2 different offices, one said I was OK,the other said I wasn't.
If they cannot decide, how the hell can I?/accountant/ agency?
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by helen7 View PostWouldn't it be deemed that the personal Self Assement was incorrect (money claimed as div's rather that paye) and therefore the personal tax will still be due.
i.e. your not off the hook if you close down the company!
I run my business they way I feel is correct. Have I been negligent doing so? No - my contracts are outside of IR35 to the best of my knowledge and to the knowledge of other external professional (lol) advisors.
(IMHO) - If the tax man decides otherwise I suppose a judge would have to decide and Hector would have to prove that I acted negligently as a director. Much harder to prove than just force his opinion on me about a contract or two.
(IMHO) - Hector is trying to collect this revenue by fear and slight of hand, like a lot of the tactics with dubious taxation.
By the way - what has happened in the high profile cases recently Dragonfly and Kingfisher etc?
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by stingman123 View PostHasn't IR35 cost them loads more than it reels in?
If they want us to pay they need to give us more carrot and less stick IMO.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by Jubber View Post
your company
i.e. your not off the hook if you close down the company!
Leave a comment:
- Home
- News & Features
- First Timers
- IR35 / S660 / BN66
- Employee Benefit Trusts
- Agency Workers Regulations
- MSC Legislation
- Limited Companies
- Dividends
- Umbrella Company
- VAT / Flat Rate VAT
- Job News & Guides
- Money News & Guides
- Guide to Contracts
- Successful Contracting
- Contracting Overseas
- Contractor Calculators
- MVL
- Contractor Expenses
Advertisers
Contractor Services
CUK News
- Streamline Your Retirement with iSIPP: A Solution for Contractor Pensions Sep 1 09:13
- Making the most of pension lump sums: overview for contractors Sep 1 08:36
- Umbrella company tribunal cases are opening up; are your wages subject to unlawful deductions, too? Aug 31 08:38
- Contractors, relabelling 'labour' as 'services' to appear 'fully contracted out' won't dupe IR35 inspectors Aug 31 08:30
- How often does HMRC check tax returns? Aug 30 08:27
- Work-life balance as an IT contractor: 5 top tips from a tech recruiter Aug 30 08:20
- Autumn Statement 2023 tipped to prioritise mental health, in a boost for UK workplaces Aug 29 08:33
- Final reminder for contractors to respond to the umbrella consultation (closing today) Aug 29 08:09
- Top 5 most in demand cyber security contract roles Aug 25 08:38
- Changes to the right to request flexible working are incoming, but how will contractors be affected? Aug 24 08:25
Leave a comment: