Climategate enquiry "unsatisfactory"

[Old Greg]

It has all the defects of religious belief.

Just wait until they start burning the heretics.

Would produce too much CO2.

[sasguru]

It is rather noticeable that our "AGW is a conspiracy theory/all scientists are in cahoots for grant money/consensus and peer review is irrelevant" believers share a common trait.
It is that they are, to a man, not as successful in the real world as their self-perceived intelligence should have led them to be, were that perception to be true.

[EternalOptimist]

Phil 'cyclops' Jones, did indeed have a shifty look about him. but I was basing my observations the comments (paraphrasing heavily here) that may the way they do things in science, buts its not the way we do things in climate science.

us, share ?? no we are climate scientists.


thats the way he came across pj

[Spacecadet]

It has all the defects of religious belief.

Just wait until they start burning the heretics.

There was that banned advert in which the non-believers were blown up

[DimPrawn]

It is rather noticeable that our "AGW is a conspiracy theory/all scientists are in cahoots for grant money/consensus and peer review is irrelevant" believers share a common trait.
It is that they are, to a man, not as successful in the real world as their self-perceived intelligence should have led them to be, were that perception to be true.

Adding zilch to the debate as usual.

Haven't you got a big spreadsheet to be updating for your superiors?

[sasguru]

Adding zilch to the debate as usual.

Haven't you got a big spreadsheet to be updating for your superiors?

Well look at it objectively:

BB
SB
DP
EO
Churchy

Ex-squaddies and/or itinerant IT jobbers. At least one a complete Walter Mitty character.

Not top-drawer or the elite by any means - and hence unlikely to have the cognitive capacity to judge complex issues like climate change.