McCanns sign Madeleine book deal

[TimberWolf]

"You brought her book up to support your argument, I demolished it"

You demolished nothing. Several other people have indicated that they believe a guilty party would have let sleeping dogs lie. I think that is a sensible view to take. You have not said why you think that is not sensible.

"Not replying should not reinforce any belief in innocence, as you appear to be doing. Your view seems to rest on it. "

Nowhere did I say that not replying reinforces innocence. I don't believe it does but neither does it reinforce guilt.


You should question why she is not answering

I have. Probably lack of confidence in the Portuguese police. A view that was vindicated when the Chief of Police (yes the guy who wrote your book) was convicted in a Portuguese court for falsifying evidence in a separate child abduction case.

I knew from past posts that your logical skills were lacking, I did not know your English comprehension and judgemental skills were at retard level too.
Keep posting though, you're doing a better job of making your cretinism obvious to the objective observer than I could.

I said her writing a book is proof of nothing and gave a counter example of the book written by the head of police. I don't argue that he and the whole Spanish police force may or may not be bent, but that makes no difference to the point. If he were bent by your 'logic' a bent person would write a book as proof and thus destroy your own argument, which was intended to support her credibility because of her writing a book. Insane either way. Forget the book.

Anyway, I'm sure most would be keen to press someone for an answer when they refuse one, and not receiving a reply would at best raise further questions. Sure the Spanish police may or may not be bent and may also have been rubbed up the wrong way, but that doesn't make her innocent or excuse not answering questions that might have assisted the case. If her lawyer had advised her against answering, the question would be why. Why. Why. Why. Get it?

[AtW]

Once you are a suspect you don't answer any questions at all.

Only if you want to appear very much guilty.

HTH

[sasguru]

I said her writing a book is proof of nothing and gave a counter example of the book written by the head of police. I don't argue that he and the whole Spanish police force may or may not be bent, but that makes no difference to the point. If he were bent by your 'logic' a bent person would write a book as proof and thus destroy your own argument, which was intended to support her credibility because of her writing a book. Insane either way. Forget the book.

Anyway, I'm sure most would be keen to press someone for an answer when they refuse one, and not receiving a reply would at best raise further questions. Sure the Spanish police may or may not be bent and may also have been rubbed up the wrong way, but that doesn't make her innocent or excuse not answering questions that might have assisted the case. If her lawyer had advised her against answering, the question would be why. Why. Why. Why. Get it?

Tenacity is a good quality when allied to intelligence.
When coupled with idiocy, however, it morphs into plain mulish stubbornness which is not a good trait.

You're not destined to rise far in this world.

HTH but IKIW.

BTW. Your lack of knowledge of where this event took place does not argue for your having a great grasp of the facts.

[SupremeSpod]

I'm waiting for "Maddie, the Musical", Music & Lyrics by Dennis Waterman.

[TimberWolf]

Tenacity is a good quality when allied to intelligence.
When coupled with idiocy, however, it morphs into plain mulish stubbornness which is not a good trait.

You're not destined to rise far in this world.

HTH but IKIW.

Rising far and intelligence are weakly correlated. As proven by you, assuming we are to believe you have risen far. More important to this questionable goal are trickery, dishonesty, deception, selfishness and psychotic tenancies. HTH.

[TimberWolf]

BTW. Your lack of knowledge of where this event took place does not argue for your having a great grasp of the facts.

My apologies to the Spanish police, replace Portuguese where I said Spanish.