Israel

[Bright Spark]

I think the USA should relocate israel to cuba, this would surely solve
all the problems in the middle east plus it would get rid of
castro as well, I doubt Hamas rockets would reach that far....

 

[Doggy Styles]

And the biggest load of rubbish is the suggestion that "It is very simple". Not bad, winning that accolade when AtW has been swlobbering all over the thread like a Poacher's dog with his banal ponderous logic. If it were in fact simple it would have been resolved decades ago. Still, as someone has already stated, TB is on the case with that lovely wife of his. So "Things can only get better!"

You're wrong. This thread started purely on the subject of the Israeli retaliation. It was not started about anything else.

So of course it's very simple. If they weren't firing rockets every day, they wouldn't have been retaliated against, those civilians would still be alive, and there would be no thread.

 

[shaunbhoy]

You're wrong. This thread started purely on the subject of the Israeli retaliation. It was not started about anything else.

So of course it's very simple. If they weren't firing rockets every day, they wouldn't have been retaliated against, those civilians would still be alive, and there would be no thread.

If you try to compartmentalise the whole Israel/palestine question into little pieces then you might feel you are simplifying matters. However, that would be to miss the whole backdrop in this instance, and that would be missing the fundamental point entirely. The israelis have been subjugating the palestinians systematically for years. The Hamas rocket attacks are only the latest in a long line of rather pointless retaliatory actions by the palestinians.

 

[EternalOptimist]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Dresden_in_World_War_II

War is not a good thing, that's why all parties should avoid getting into it.

war is organised violence
violence is part of the human condition
if you do something, do it properly
therefore war is a good thing
and all parties should avoid getting out of it


hic

 

[Cyberman]

You're wrong. This thread started purely on the subject of the Israeli retaliation. It was not started about anything else.

So of course it's very simple. If they weren't firing rockets every day, they wouldn't have been retaliated against, those civilians would still be alive, and there would be no thread.

Absolutely correct !! Hamas announced last week they would not adhere to the peace treaty with Israel , and so they are reaping the rewards of their own stupidity.

 

[AtW]

The israelis have been subjugating the palestinians systematically for years.

It seems to me that Israelies mainly want to avoid being shelled by rockets and mortar shells, not being suicide bombed and stuff like that - pretty reasonable desire in my view.

 

[minestrone]

It seems to me that Israelies mainly want to avoid being shelled by rockets and mortar shells, not being suicide bombed and stuff like that - pretty reasonable desire in my view.

So I think we have came full circle back to the very first point I made, you drop bombs on them, they will drop bombs on you.

There will be a suicide attack in the next few days and then another bombing.

It is not about who is right, it is about who will stop.

 

[AtW]

It is not about who is right, it is about who will stop.

HAMAS was sending rockets for many weeks now on Israel - there was no bombing in response, it just they really took the piss in the last few days and finally got what they deserved.

 

[ace00]

It is not about who is right, it is about who will stop.

Palestinians have been offered 93% of pre 1967 territory + billions in aid to construct a new and viable state but they have refused it. The Arab leaders don't want the violence to end.

 

[Paddy]

Palestinians have been offered 93% of pre 1967 territory + billions in aid to construct a new and viable state but they have refused it. The Arab leaders don't want the violence to end.

Can you show a link to where you got this information?