FWIW, I noticed the missing forum button too, but it didn't bother me much because I always found it slightly annoying that it took me back to the home page.
One of the main issues I had with the so-called tab bar was that it didn't act like a tab bar does: in reality it was just some links, dressed up to
look like a tab bar.
For example, if I went to advanced search and looked for stuff posted by a specific user in Technical between certain dates, I'd get a page of results with the "What's New" tab highlighted. (This didn't make any sense to start with, so let's say we change the tab to "Search Results".) Now the problem is that, if I click on the "Forum" tab, I go to the forum home page, but when I click on the "Search Results" tab again, I don't go back to my previous results: I go to the results of a "What's New" search. In fact there's no way to get back to my search results other than by using the Back button or repeating the search. It also suggests that the tab should constantly change its title, which isn't what tabs do: even on MS's weird multiline tab bars, they don't actually change their names, they just move around unpredictably.
Similarly, if I'm in, say, Technical, the "Forum" tab is highlighted. If I click on "What's New" and then re-select the "Forum" tab, it takes me back to the home page.
The whole tab metaphor is fundamentally broken: they aren't tabs at all. The problem is that vBulletin had to have a UI that could cope with a bunch of new stuff they've added to their overall suite (none of which is used here), and they let the graphic designers loose on it instead of the interaction designers. Any ID worth their salt would understand that navigating between different components of a site (forum, blogs, search, etc.) is not the same as switching among multiple views in an application (e.g. most preference dialogs, or a tabbed browser) and therefore the tab metaphor is not only inappropriate, but misleading.
Getting rid of the tabs has revealed that the previously-unnoticed changes they've made to the breadcrumb trail (for no readily apparent reason) mean that it isn't good enough, so I'm going to fix it. With a bit of luck, everybody will then be happy.
Actually, I think I'll make a nice cup of tea before getting back to it
