- Joined
- Aug 27, 2007
- Messages
- 28,185
- Likes received
- 8,675
- Thanks received
- 2,403
- Location
- Far away from HMRC
The Inland Revenue have a new machine that can detect IR35-caught contractors. It's good, at 90% accurate (10% false positives). As the machine scans this years self-assessment papers 3,000 contractors are tested and the first 30 escape detection, while the 31st fails. How sure are you that this person is due a lengthy legal battle?
I get you - it's a logic/maths problem.
The first 30 escape detection - do you mean "the first thirty who are tax evading scumbags", or "the first thirty tested"?
If the former, then I'm a 100% sure - unless they roll-over and admit guilt immediately.
If the latter (which I guess you really mean), then it's all about expectation probability. What is the expectation that the 31st person will be flagged up by the machine?
Now, one in ten of those flagged up will be innocent. The chance of it being a specific individual of the 3000 is 1/3000. So, the chances that the 31st person is guilty, is:
1/3000 * 9/10 = 9/30000 = 3/10000 = 0.03%.
Which is probably wrong, especially as it isn't one of the options, but also expectation probability makes my head hurt.