• Want to receive the latest contracting news and advice straight to your inbox? Sign up to the ContractorUK newsletter here. Every sign up will also be entered into a draw to WIN £100 Amazon vouchers!

Partition

Mailman

Super poster
Joined
Jul 7, 2005
Messages
2,533
Likes received
0
Thanks received
0
See, this is the thing I dont get.

How come when India was partitioned in to India and Pakistan it was Pakistan that went to crap and India that prospered?

Was it cause all the religious fundies moved out of India?

Mailman
 
Mailman said:
See, this is the thing I dont get.

How come when India was partitioned in to India and Pakistan it was Pakistan that went to crap and India that prospered?

Was it cause all the religious fundies moved out of India?

Mailman

Well, India is a bigger country with more resources, which must help.

However, I think what you're driving at is that Islamism is an inhibiting force to economic and social development - in which case I agree.
 
Mailman said:
See, this is the thing I dont get.
You don't get a lot of stuff do you MM? Economics really isn't your forte is it? Didn't you claim that leading economists predicted that the US$ would actually rise as result of oil being traded in Euros? Any luck with the names of these economists or are you still avoiding the question?! :rollin:

IMO the economic plight pf Pakistan has little to do with religion. Pakistan has suffered as result of the rampant corruption at the highest levels of government for decades. Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif, who are actually quite secular in their outlook, took the country to within an inch of bankruptcy in the 80s and 90s. This is part of the reason why the population of Pakistan were actually happy at the arrival of Musharaff who is a military dictator. I'd actually find that quite funny if it wasn't so tragic!

The economy Pakistan has come on leaps and bounds over the last 5 years or so. You might be surprised to know that this was also a period in which 'religion-orientated' politcians presided in local government. If Pakistan can sort out it’s law and order situation, work on education and create a stabile environment for foreign investment, I think it, along with India, China and the lesser known economies of the Far East will grow at ever faster rates.
 
Gee, I thought the reason pakistan has come so far was because of all the economic aid they get from secular countries :D

Mailman
 
Mailman said:
Gee, I thought the reason pakistan has come so far was because of all the economic aid they get from secular countries :D

Mailman


Incidentally, the UK kindly gives India a couple of hundred million per year in "aid"

It must be to help them build more call centres so they can take even more jobs away from the UK

I am sure they will reciprocate the generoisty when the UK is bankrupt

Its all about "fairness" after all
 
Mailman said:
Gee, I thought the reason pakistan has come so far was because of all the economic aid they get from secular countries :D
Mailman
Surely not the only reason? In your world maybe! A world in which everything is either black or white, mad mullah or gleaming athiest, where there's only ever one explanation to every question. Personally, I think there's probably more than one reason behind Pakistan's economic progress in recent times. However, it's interesting to see that you've moved the debate on from 'the mad-mullahs are complete failures' to 'the mad-mullahs are only succesful because we give them money'. Small but welcome progress MM. Well done! :rollin:
 
Mind you...for all this so called advancement you are so keen on it really doesnt take much to show the true underbelly of the pakistani miracle :D

Mailman
 
Mailman said:
Mind you...for all this so called advancement you are so keen on it really doesnt take much to show the true underbelly of the pakistani miracle :D
Mailman
Hardly a miracle by any stretch of the imagination. I was merely correcting your, as per usual, OTT observation that 'Pakistan went to crap' after partition. Your obsession with stereotypes obviously left you unaware that the key economics indicators of the Pakistani economy have actually been good in recent times and they are actually making 'progress'. As is the case with you, the progress is small but welcome nonetheless. :D
 
ALM said:
Hardly a miracle by any stretch of the imagination.

Hurray, you are coming round at last to our way of thinking! :D

There is no life without wife! :D

Mailman
 
Mailman said:
Hurray, you are coming round at last to our way of thinking! :D

There is no life without wife! :D

Mailman

You really are a bit dim aren't you? Are you a big hitter in the City by any chance?
 

Advertisers

Back
Top