There is no such thing as non profit. If the railways are run by the public sector they may indeed not show that they are being run for hard cash, but they will most certainly be run for what I call "hidden profit"
Who will profit?
Firstly the government. They will ultimately control the money that goes into the rail and will probably spend it according to what influences voters.
Secondly it willl profit those who run it. These people will seek to exploit their monopoly to become unaccountable, to screw as much money as they can and to silence the consumer. Thirdly come those who work on the railways. They will exploit their power to protect their jobs, get as much money as they can, and not be responsible to either their bosses or to the consumer.
So if you fools STILL believe after all these years of corruption and incompetence, that this or any other govt is either capable or willing to run anything for the benefit of anyone other than themselves, then frankly you deserve whatever govt dishes out.