• Want to receive the latest contracting news and advice straight to your inbox? Sign up to the ContractorUK newsletter here. Every sign up will also be entered into a draw to WIN £100 Amazon vouchers!

West 28th Street Limited

3.33 star(s)
By the way - I still don't think all people out of those 3k+ will receive court papers.

It's not sensible to a campaign that can actually really go sideways if a single person wins them.

Hard to see how a court order and a validation order can land for one person and not for another.
Maybe they take those to court that are only represented in a single solicitor group? Leave individuals alone? I.e. the cheapest route. But then all individuals will likely be time limited - so they lose any legal right to enforce.
 
I really can't personally comment on those who are a group and the technicalities of the cost. And if that can be done as a class-like action. Maybe @coveredname can comment.

Also the other issue about being time barred, I don't yet see how that is currently factual. Yes a date was mentioned by the fca - 13 Nov. However I don't think we have seen anything to substantiate that, and how it came to be. This must have come as the result of that agreement with ethica, when they put on the restrictions, but I don't think we seen yet the importance of that date.

Lastly and this is where I put all hope, and once again thank you to the brilliance of people to suggest to complain to the fca, i think the way the fca has acted has suffocated already this campaign.

It seems to me that the card to pay them voluntarily is completely burnt.
It further seems that the fact that the fca expressly asked to be reported as to who paid, how much, and where the money is held is suffocating the ongoing cashflows.

It seems to be the force admittance that they both need the fca to grant this VO and you have to be beaten in court that is raising a massive mount for them to climb.

Further if indeed it costs at least 500£ per person to initiate court papers. A fee you have to pay upfront, only lowered bound by 5% of what they claim against each individual, that it would cost them 10's of millions to actually send papers to all 3000 of us.

It is only a guess they will only try a handful.

In conclusion we really need to get the facts on what are the limitations here. We need to be sure that there are rather than to just guess.
 
I really can't personally comment on those who are a group and the technicalities of the cost. And if that can be done as a class-like action. Maybe @coveredname can comment.

Also the other issue about being time barred, I don't yet see how that is currently factual. Yes a date was mentioned by the fca - 13 Nov. However I don't think we have seen anything to substantiate that, and how it came to be. This must have come as the result of that agreement with ethica, when they put on the restrictions, but I don't think we seen yet the importance of that date.

Lastly and this is where I put all hope, and once again thank you to the brilliance of people to suggest to complain to the fca, i think the way the fca has acted has suffocated already this campaign.

It seems to me that the card to pay them voluntarily is completely burnt.
It further seems that the fact that the fca expressly asked to be reported as to who paid, how much, and where the money is held is suffocating the ongoing cashflows.

It seems to be the force admittance that they both need the fca to grant this VO and you have to be beaten in court that is raising a massive mount for them to climb.

Further if indeed it costs at least 500£ per person to initiate court papers. A fee you have to pay upfront, only lowered bound by 5% of what they claim against each individual, that it would cost them 10's of millions to actually send papers to all 3000 of us.

It is only a guess they will only try a handful.

In conclusion we really need to get the facts on what are the limitations here. We need to be sure that there are rather than to just guess.
Some figures:

1. Issue Fees (Paid when filing the claim)
The initial fee depends on how much money you are trying to recover: [1, 2]

Claim ValueIssue Fee
Up to £300£35
More than £300 up to £500£50
More than £500 up to £1,000£70
More than £1,000 up to £1,500£80
More than £1,500 up to £3,000£115
More than £3,000 up to £5,000£205
More than £5,000 up to £10,000£455
More than £10,000 up to £200,0005% of the claim value
Over £200,000£10,000 (maximum)
 
Some figures:

1. Issue Fees (Paid when filing the claim)
The initial fee depends on how much money you are trying to recover: [1, 2]

Claim ValueIssue Fee
Up to £300£35
More than £300 up to £500£50
More than £500 up to £1,000£70
More than £1,000 up to £1,500£80
More than £1,500 up to £3,000£115
More than £3,000 up to £5,000£205
More than £5,000 up to £10,000£455
More than £10,000 up to £200,0005% of the claim value
Over £200,000£10,000 (maximum)
I wonder if they can pay £10,000 and name all Elysium’s members in a single claim?
 
I don't know, but it's hard to see how they could potentially bring a claim against hundreds of individuals, all who may have a different angle to their case and defence, in a single claim. Basically, Elysium will be "defending" multiple people and multiple schemes over multiple dates.....how can that be considered a single claim....I can't see it.
 
Maybe they take those to court that are only represented in a single solicitor group? Leave individuals alone? I.e. the cheapest route. But then all individuals will likely be time limited - so they lose any legal right to enforce.
I'm yet to believe that Greenwoods is as trustworthy as they set out to be, I'm not convinced ..... is there any that can be trusted in advance
 
I spent the morning on this with ai.
Not advisable because it can hallucinate.

It gave me 3-4 options that may be considered by w28.

The safest option to protect their 3200 portfolio would be to issue a claim against all individually, to avoid time limitations (if those true). Thats north of 8mil.

The only way it can get cheaper is if they found common features, and bundle defendants together, but that is not based on how we are represented, but rather on commonalities of our arrangements.
Say common providers common periods etc.

But that bears risk on losing the entire bundle as any test cases taken, then their verdicts are tying to the bundle. So even if they were able to group people together in favour of paying a max cap of 10k to the bundle (something I read about a cap on 200k) theres risks.

There's also a lot of ambiguity here for me:
Say you bundled 100 people on common features. Say 90 are in an action group, and say they choose one of the remaining 10, who is for arguments sake represented badly and loses on an important binding point. Where does that leave the 90 who paid to be part of a group defence? It's all very blurred truly.

But the FCA has severely damaged the campaign.

A statement of fact is that now noone can be forced to pay without a validation order and a court ruling. And that is truly a breakthrough since the felicitas days.
Back then they were just shaking the tree without daring going to the courts.

Now they have to use them, and i costs.

(Having said all of that, the 13Nov deadline mystifies me)
 
Along with VO they also need a court enforcement order based on what fca published. It is a specific statutory court order under CCA 1974 on a few possible sections based on exact breach (s 127/65/170/40). They must persuade a judge to grant that. Which is entirely separate to simply filing a standard debt collection claim against us in court.

Because the originators and later alleged assignees failed to hold the required FCA/OFT CC authorisations or breached mandatory CCA rules, the agreements are *legally unenforceable* unless Whopper street clears these two first (VO & court order).

***Not a legal advice, based on own research - correct above if you come to a different result please
 
I may now have a theory, after combining what @MrO666 said, and what I did with AI. And it gets a bit twisted, but is a theory nontheless.

People bundling up with Elysium might actually been favoured by w28. Any bundling for that matter, not bringing specific attention to Elysium in itself.

So I hear a good 600-700 people signed up with them. All well intended.

Now w28 rolled the dice to see who is with who with Elysium based on the responses (here I am assuming individuals had their solicitors responding and not the solicitors advising what people should write but not disclosing they were with Elysium).

So now that forms a map for w28:
I have 600 people all represented by the same shop. How can these be dissected into bundles to formulate groups.
It would be large be a spreadsheet exercice.

Say it is 10 groups.
You litigate them in bundles on features all under elysium.

10 bundles cost 100k.
600 people would have otherwise cost about 2mil to litigate individually.

1/20th- fold cost benefit for 20% sample of the entire population of affected people.

And they litigate on those 600 people alone.

Don't get me wrong the defence under a group is extremely valuable to the individuals using it indeed - no judgement.
And it would for sure be tougher to beat.

But paying 2mil to litigate 600 people with better odds may still be very difficult on costs.

But paying 100k to litigate 600 people on elysium with worse odds might be favourable to w28 on the 1/20th cost alone.
 

Advertisers

Back
Top