• Want to receive the latest contracting news and advice straight to your inbox? Sign up to the ContractorUK newsletter here. Every sign up will also be entered into a draw to WIN £100 Amazon vouchers!

West 28th Street Limited

3.36 star(s)
I received half a tree trunk myself on Saturday, it just does not want to go away!

I arranged a call with Elysium Law on the Saturday for this morning but just received an email stating that they have had a large number of enquires this morning so will be sending out an email to all affected, I think they have all the details already and will come back with a suitable response.

I have not spoken to Elysium before and being honest I just ignored the previous requests for money but this time would like it knocked on the head once and for all, I read that they would split the cost between those that have signed up and are willing to proceed as a collective but don't quote me on that.

Anyway I am on the mailing list so will post details of what I receive back then any that want to make a judgement call can do so.
 
Debt Crystallisation

An admission of debt that has crystallised means that a debtor has formally acknowledged a specific amount of money is owed to a creditor, and that debt is now fixed, due, and legally binding.

In legal and financial terms, "crystallised" means changing from a potential or contingent liability into a concrete, legally enforceable obligation.


Be careful that you do not say anything that 'crystallises' the alleged debt.
 
Last edited: 11:46
Hello

I don't really understand with this debacle how HMRC can demand payment on a loan, and then this delightful company can then demand the loan back.

For my simple mind, we either pay the revised amount of tax on the loan that HMRC demanded, or we repay the loan to this company. If we repay the loan, (meaning that ultimately we were not paid), then how can we be paying tax (revised or otherwise) to HMRC? I'm confused!
 
  • Like
Reactions: DHW
Hello

I don't really understand with this debacle how HMRC can demand payment on a loan, and then this delightful company can then demand the loan back.

For my simple mind, we either pay the revised amount of tax on the loan that HMRC demanded, or we repay the loan to this company. If we repay the loan, (meaning that ultimately we were not paid), then how can we be paying tax (revised or otherwise) to HMRC? I'm confused!

Technically funds can be both a loan and income, but that has been covered a number of times elsehwere.

In summary, HMRC will be exceptionally unlikely to ever refund you a penny. If you settled with HMRC, then I believe the wording they offered states something about you never getting the money back (not in those words obvisouly). HMRC will always insist it was disguised income, hence tax was due.

The general thinking across this forum and also a number of legal snippets that many have seen, is that these monies were not bona-fide loans and are not repayable, although some may have other views.

Just take a breath and whatever you do, do NOT acknowledge that any loan took place or debt exists........
 
Last edited: 13:08
Hello

I don't really understand with this debacle how HMRC can demand payment on a loan, and then this delightful company can then demand the loan back.

For my simple mind, we either pay the revised amount of tax on the loan that HMRC demanded, or we repay the loan to this company. If we repay the loan, (meaning that ultimately we were not paid), then how can we be paying tax (revised or otherwise) to HMRC? I'm confused!

Let's repeat my post from October 2020


My concern would be that the actual matter that a court would care about is literally just the bit in Bold below

your work > xyz > trust > your bank account

And the bit in Red isn't important for West 28th Street and the courts, for them all that matters is just the story of the money from the trust and the bank account.

The thing is that this is Schrodinger's Money because as with his cat depending on how you look at the money it can be income (if you look at step 1 to 4) and a loan (steps 3 to 4) at the same time. It very much depends on who is looking and West 28th are looking at just steps 3 and 4 and thinking I could get some money here...
 
Last edited: 13:30
I have also emailed Elysium and was told they will contact this week.
I will update when I receive anything
 
I disputed my Felicitas SD to Gladstones and had confirmation of the letter being signed for in early 2020. They never wrote back and I haven't heard anything since. The recent letter was not a demand - would it be wise to wait until such demand is made before engaging, or stay on top and dispute to Trethowans? I'd probably use the same template which was actually posted on here (closed thread with 180+ pages).
 
I also received one of these today, dated the 24th April and arrived today (25th April). It feels like this letter is positioning to start taking action against me.

Searching google I saw that there was some action taken by Elysium Law back in August 2024 against 28th West West 28th Street Demands: Why Contractors Should Wait - Elysium Law I have sent them an email asking to join their group action - it might be too late to join that specific one, but it seems that the scheming felicitas have sold this allged loan to another company and they are also chancing their arm on trying to recover something that is not legally owed. I made such a mistake believing the phony QC approved ways to reduce the tax burden. I settled with HMRC, now these sharks are trying to get more money from me.

It is depressing...

Well, it took 30 seconds to get to the first red flag, and it’s a famous one.
Kenneth Arnold (director of W28th) used to be a director or Montpellier.

About the only other thing to trump that would be if he has links to AML


It looks like this is Ken Arnold previously of Montpellier and now director of West 28th Street Ltd
https://www.coldbathsolutions.co.uk/about/
Ken Arnold | LinkedIn

It seems like he makes a living trying to scrape from the bottom of the barrel.

its nice to put a face to a name
 
Last edited: 16:19
hi All,
I've received documents from Trethowan LLP. Back in 2020 i disputed any such demands and statements from both Felicitas and 28th West street. Im not sure what this now means. I paid monies to HMRC as they adjudged it as not loans. Ive had a stroke in 2020 and my anxiety its thrus the roof. Any help greatly appreciated.
 
hi All,
I've received documents from Trethowan LLP. Back in 2020 i disputed any such demands and statements from both Felicitas and 28th West street. Im not sure what this now means. I paid monies to HMRC as they adjudged it as not loans. Ive had a stroke in 2020 and my anxiety its thrus the roof. Any help greatly appreciated.

So let's break it down

West 28th Street are trying to resurrect the loans that you disputed with both Felicitas and 28th West street back in 2020-3. The big bundle of papers sent on Friday was designed to legitimise the "loans" so they can attempt to claim the money again. At some point you will need to send another dispute letter regarding the "loans" but that may not be now..

on your other point the fact you paid HMRC is, sadly, not relevant here because as I covered early HMRC looks at steps 1 and 4 below and the others are looking at steps 3 and 4.

your work > xyz > trust > your bank account

Sadly both 1 and 4 (it's income where tax is owed) and steps 3 and 4 (it's a loan) may be valid depending on other factors.
 

Advertisers

Back
Top