The Tory graph is spot on here for once. I should say we add Southampton & Swindon to the list, how else will London continue to prosper if we don't start closing those sink estates?
Ministers urged to forget about saving 'failing' cities and towns such as Hull, Hartlepool and Burnley - Telegraph
Ministers urged to forget about saving 'failing' cities and towns such as Hull, Hartlepool and Burnley
The Economist magazine said that despite years of Government money and "heroic" efforts the towns were decaying and it was time for a change in policy.
The globally-respected publication, in an editorial entitled 'City Sicker', said the fate of the once confident places was "sad".
But it urged ministers to forget about using tax breaks or spending money to encourage people to go the cities and towns as it diverted them from areas where "they would be more successful".
The Economist cited the example of the Cotswolds, once an industrial engine and now so pretty because "centuries ago, huge numbers of people fled them".
In a withering verdict, the magazine said: "Despite dollops of public money and years of heroic effort, a string of towns and smallish cities in Britain's former industrial heartlands are quietly decaying.
"Middlesbrough, Burnley, Hartlepool, Hull and many others were in trouble even before the financial crisis.
It added: "That so many well intentioned people are trying so hard to save them suggests how much affection they claim.
"But these kindly efforts are misguided, Governments should not try to rescue failing towns. Instead they should support the people who live in them.
"That means helping them to commute or move to places where there are jobs - and giving them the skills to get those jobs."
The Economist argued more money should go in schools in the "urban ghost towns" and the transport network should be upgraded so it's possible to run more regional services to each of them.
The controversial article comes as Hull bids to be voted the 2017 City of Culture. The city is down to the last four in a race even locals thought they would never win.
And Burnley two months ago was voted the most enterprising area of the UK for its "pioneering" culture and economic prospects.
Despite these successes, experts claim the north-south divide is growing with house prices in southern England now more than £100,000 more expensive than those in the north.
The Economist argued that unemployment rates in the "failing" cities and towns were double the national averge and the high streets are dominated with betting shops and payday lenders. Wolverhampton, it said, was among the worst have "condemned parts of its town centre for a shopping mall that never came".
It said that in Wolverhampton 22 per cent of the people have no qualifications - and the overall performance of schools in Hull and Hartlepool is "appalling".
It added: "Even with growth, the most ambitions and best-educated people will still tend to leave places like Hull. Their size, location and demographics means theat they will never offer the sorts of restaurants or shops that the middle classes like."
Michelle Dewberry, the Hull-born winner of BBC's The Apprentice in 2006, told the Daily Telegraph the article was an "insult".
She said: "For people to give up on an entire city, it's insulting to the people. We have the BBC there, Siemens, there's lots more investment.
"The people shouldn't be told to get out but they should be helped, the entrepreneurial spirit should come from within. The city deserves a say when the ambition for it dies."
A spokesman for Hartlepool County Council added: "We know unemployment is high but there are tremendous amount of positives. We know what the problems are."
Ministers urged to forget about saving 'failing' cities and towns such as Hull, Hartlepool and Burnley - Telegraph
Ministers urged to forget about saving 'failing' cities and towns such as Hull, Hartlepool and Burnley
The Economist magazine said that despite years of Government money and "heroic" efforts the towns were decaying and it was time for a change in policy.
The globally-respected publication, in an editorial entitled 'City Sicker', said the fate of the once confident places was "sad".
But it urged ministers to forget about using tax breaks or spending money to encourage people to go the cities and towns as it diverted them from areas where "they would be more successful".
The Economist cited the example of the Cotswolds, once an industrial engine and now so pretty because "centuries ago, huge numbers of people fled them".
In a withering verdict, the magazine said: "Despite dollops of public money and years of heroic effort, a string of towns and smallish cities in Britain's former industrial heartlands are quietly decaying.
"Middlesbrough, Burnley, Hartlepool, Hull and many others were in trouble even before the financial crisis.
It added: "That so many well intentioned people are trying so hard to save them suggests how much affection they claim.
"But these kindly efforts are misguided, Governments should not try to rescue failing towns. Instead they should support the people who live in them.
"That means helping them to commute or move to places where there are jobs - and giving them the skills to get those jobs."
The Economist argued more money should go in schools in the "urban ghost towns" and the transport network should be upgraded so it's possible to run more regional services to each of them.
The controversial article comes as Hull bids to be voted the 2017 City of Culture. The city is down to the last four in a race even locals thought they would never win.
And Burnley two months ago was voted the most enterprising area of the UK for its "pioneering" culture and economic prospects.
Despite these successes, experts claim the north-south divide is growing with house prices in southern England now more than £100,000 more expensive than those in the north.
The Economist argued that unemployment rates in the "failing" cities and towns were double the national averge and the high streets are dominated with betting shops and payday lenders. Wolverhampton, it said, was among the worst have "condemned parts of its town centre for a shopping mall that never came".
It said that in Wolverhampton 22 per cent of the people have no qualifications - and the overall performance of schools in Hull and Hartlepool is "appalling".
It added: "Even with growth, the most ambitions and best-educated people will still tend to leave places like Hull. Their size, location and demographics means theat they will never offer the sorts of restaurants or shops that the middle classes like."
Michelle Dewberry, the Hull-born winner of BBC's The Apprentice in 2006, told the Daily Telegraph the article was an "insult".
She said: "For people to give up on an entire city, it's insulting to the people. We have the BBC there, Siemens, there's lots more investment.
"The people shouldn't be told to get out but they should be helped, the entrepreneurial spirit should come from within. The city deserves a say when the ambition for it dies."
A spokesman for Hartlepool County Council added: "We know unemployment is high but there are tremendous amount of positives. We know what the problems are."
Comment