• Visitors can check out the Forum FAQ by clicking this link. You have to register before you can post: click the REGISTER link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. View our Forum Privacy Policy.
  • Want to receive the latest contracting news and advice straight to your inbox? Sign up to the ContractorUK newsletter here. Every sign up will also be entered into a draw to WIN £100 Amazon vouchers!

Word on the Arab Street

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Word on the Arab Street

    Listen to the word on the 'Arab street'

    By Mark Steyn The Telegraph
    (Filed: 22/11/2005)

    Rumours of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi's death may be exaggerated. He was reported by several Arab TV networks to have been among eight terrorists who self-detonated in Mosul on Sunday. Still, whether or not he's sleeping with the fishes or the 72 virgins, he's already outlived whatever usefulness he had to the jihad.

    On Friday, the allegedly explosive "Arab street" finally exploded, in the largest demonstration against al-Qa'eda or its affiliates seen in the Middle East. "Zarqawi," shouted 200,000 Jordanians, "from Amman we say to you, you are a coward!" Also "the enemy of Allah" - which, for a jihadist, isn't what they call on Broadway a money review.

    The old head-hacker was sufficiently rattled by the critical pans of his Jordanian hotel bombings that he issued the first IRA-style apology in al-Qa'eda's history. "People of Jordan, we did not undertake to blow up any wedding parties," he said. "For those Muslims who were killed, we ask God to show them mercy, for they were not targets." Yeah, right. Tell it to the non-Marines. It was perfectly obvious to Ali Hussein Ali al-Shamari and his missus what was going on when they strolled into the ballroom of the Radisson Hotel.

    Still, Mr Zarqawi has now announced his intention to decapitate King Abdullah. "Your star is fading," he declared. "You will not escape your fate, you descendant of traitors. We will be able to reach your head and chop it off."

    Good luck, pal. I don't know what Islamist Suicide-Bombing For Dummies defines as a "soft target" but a Jordanian-Palestinian wedding in the public area of an hotel in a Muslim country with no infidel troops must come pretty close to the softest target of all time. Even more revealing, look at who Zarqawi dispatched to blow up his brother Muslims: why would he send Ali Hussein Ali al-Shamari, one of his most trusted lieutenants, to die in an operation requiring practically no skill?

    Well, by definition it's hard to get suicide bombers with experience. But Mr Shamari's presence suggests at the very least that the "insurgency" is having a hard time meeting its recruitment targets. Though it's much admired in the salons of the West, armchair insurgents such as Michael Moore seem to have no desire to walk the walk. Mr Moore compared the Zarqawi crowd to the "Minutemen" of America's revolution, pledged to take to the field of battle at a minute's notice. Alas, the concept of self-destructing Minutemen depends on the often misplaced optimism of the London bus stop: there'll be another one along in a minute.

    Mrs Shamari's brother, Thamir al-Rashawi, Zarqawi's right-hand man and the "Emir of al-Anbar" (i.e., the Sunni Triangle), was killed by US troops in Fallujah last year. Her other two brothers and her brother-in-law all died in engagements with the enemy this year. Sending a surviving member of your rapidly dwindling inner circle to blow up a Palestinian wedding is not a sign of strength.

    True, he did manage to kill a couple of dozen Muslims. But what's the strategic value of that? Presumably, it's an old-fashioned mob heavy's way of keeping the locals in line. And that worked out well, didn't it? Hundreds of thousands of Zarqawi's fellow Jordanians fill the streets to demand his death.

    Did they show that on the BBC? Or are demonstrations only news when they're anti-Bush and anti-Blair? And look at it this way: if the "occupation" is so unpopular in Iraq, where are the mass demonstrations against that? I'm not talking 200,000, or even 100 or 50,000. But, if there were just 1,500 folks shouting "Great Satan, go home!" in Baghdad or Mosul, it would be large enough for the media to do that little trick where they film the demo close up so it looks like the place is packed. Yet no such demonstrations take place.

    Happily for Mr Zarqawi, no matter how desperate the head-hackers get, the Western defeatists can always top them. A Democrat Congressman, Jack Murtha, has called for immediate US withdrawal from Iraq. He's a Vietnam veteran, so naturally the media are insisting that his views warrant special deference, military experience in a war America lost being the only military experience the Democrats and the press value these days. Hence, the demand for the President to come up with an "exit strategy".

    In war, there are usually only two exit strategies: victory or defeat. The latter's easier. Just say, whoa, we're the world's pre-eminent power but we can't handle an unprecedently low level of casualties, so if you don't mind we'd just as soon get off at the next stop.

    Demonstrating the will to lose as clearly as America did in Vietnam wasn't such a smart move, but since the media can't seem to get beyond this ancient jungle war it may be worth underlining the principal difference: Osama is not Ho Chi Minh, and al-Qa'eda are not the Viet Cong. If you exit, they'll follow. And Americans will die - in foreign embassies, barracks, warships, as they did through the Nineties, and eventually on the streets of US cities, too.

    As 9/11 fades into the past, that's an increasingly hard argument to make. Taking your ball and going home is a seductive argument in a paradoxical superpower whose inclinations on the Right have a strong isolationist streak and on the Left a strong transnational streak - which is isolationism with a sappy face and biennial black-tie banquets in EU capitals. Transnationalism means poseur solutions - the Kyotification of foreign policy.

    So, just as things are looking up on the distant, eastern front, they're wobbling badly on the home front. Anti-Bush Continentals who would welcome a perceived American defeat in Iraq ought to remember the third front in this war: Europe is both a home front and a foreign battleground - as the Dutch have learnt, watching the land of the bicycling Queen transformed into 24-hour armed security for even minor municipal officials. In this war, for Europeans the faraway country of which they know little turns out to be their own. Much as the Guardian and Le Monde would enjoy it, an America that turns its back on the world is the last thing you need.

    --------------------------------------------------------------------
    Hear hear!!
    Sola gratia

    Sola fide

    Soli Deo gloria

    #2
    Yes we've done a good job handing over power in Iraq to the Iranian controlled "democrats". There's only one winner in this and it ain't us. Staying or going now or in the future makes not a whit of difference.
    Those who have eyes see, those who have ears hear.
    Hard Brexit now!
    #prayfornodeal

    Comment


      #3
      As 9/11 fades into the past, that's an increasingly hard argument to make

      What has nine eleven got to do with the invasion of Iraq ?

      Case dismissed.

      Next .

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by AlfredJPruffock
        As 9/11 fades into the past, that's an increasingly hard argument to make

        What has nine eleven got to do with the invasion of Iraq ?

        Case dismissed.

        Next .

        Hindsight is a wonderful thing isn't it? Post 9/11 the whole world believed Saddam was acquiring WMD. So what should the US have done put their national interests in the hands of corrupt French and Russian "fingers in the oil barrels" self serving criminals. Saddam was given a final opportunity (1441) and he did not comply. Period. I rest my case.
        Sola gratia

        Sola fide

        Soli Deo gloria

        Comment


          #5
          The ex editor of the Telegraph was on Newnight last night. He reckon he'd rather read the Guardian now than the "American Neo con propaganda sheet the Telegraph has become under Black".
          The court heard Darren Upton had written a letter to Judge Sally Cahill QC saying he wasn’t “a typical inmate of prison”.

          But the judge said: “That simply demonstrates your arrogance continues. You are typical. Inmates of prison are people who are dishonest. You are a thoroughly dishonestly man motivated by your own selfish greed.”

          Comment


            #6
            Mark Steyn

            Whether you agree with Mark Steyn (and I do) or not he is a brilliant writer.
            What he says is true. If Alf cannot come to terms with the concept of cause and effect (convenient for the guilt ridden anti war brigade) then I would suggest that had 9/11 not happened then the US would not have invaded Iraq.
            Let us not forget EU open doors immigration benefits IT contractors more than anyone

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by Bagpuss
              The ex editor of the Telegraph was on Newnight last night. He reckon he'd rather read the Guardian now than the "American Neo con propaganda sheet the Telegraph has become under Black".
              Then give an example (and Black no longer owns the Telegraph anyway)
              Let us not forget EU open doors immigration benefits IT contractors more than anyone

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by DodgyAgent
                Whether you agree with Mark Steyn (and I do) or not he is a brilliant writer.
                What he says is true. If Alf cannot come to terms with the concept of cause and effect (convenient for the guilt ridden anti war brigade) then I would suggest that had 9/11 not happened then the US would not have invaded Iraq.
                Dodgy, what does handing over Iraq to effective Iranian control achieve? What has the Iraq war achieved in general?
                Hard Brexit now!
                #prayfornodeal

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by DodgyAgent
                  Whether you agree with Mark Steyn (and I do) or not he is a brilliant writer.
                  What he says is true. If Alf cannot come to terms with the concept of cause and effect (convenient for the guilt ridden anti war brigade) then I would suggest that had 9/11 not happened then the US would not have invaded Iraq.

                  DA

                  Well there are others who disagree that the invasion of Iraq would have happened sans 9 11, for example from todays Independent ... and even the CIA confimned there was no linakge between Iraq and Al Queda etc, given Saddams secular regeime perhaps this is not totally surprising.

                  PS for what is worth I was for a War for regeime change against Saudi Arabia not Iraq.

                  Earlier this year a BBC Newsnight report claimed to have uncovered documents showing the Bush administration made plans to secure Iraqi oil even before the 9/11 terrorist attacks on the US.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Hindsight is a wonderful thing isn't it? Post 9/11 the whole world believed Saddam was acquiring WMD
                    Untrue , and the best people to know would have been the UN Nuclear Inspectorate whose claims that Iraq had no WMDs were confirmed.

                    But that did not matter as according to Mr Blair there was no time left for such considerations.

                    BTW Chico you seem to be avoiding any criticism of the vile regieme in Saudia Arabia , why is that ?

                    PS DA as you probably aware Mr Black has more pressing concerns than discussing the politics of the press for the moment ....
                    Last edited by AlfredJPruffock; 22 November 2005, 13:42.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X