• Visitors can check out the Forum FAQ by clicking this link. You have to register before you can post: click the REGISTER link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. View our Forum Privacy Policy.
  • Want to receive the latest contracting news and advice straight to your inbox? Sign up to the ContractorUK newsletter here. Every sign up will also be entered into a draw to WIN £100 Amazon vouchers!

Horizon exit opportunity (Non-Big Group discussion thread)

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #11
    Being very naive, if the loan is paid off will it be reported to HRMC in 2019.
    Are they saying that every single loan ever made since 1999 has to be declared and if paid off, how and how much and when it was repaid?
    Is it just EBT loans contractors loans etc.?

    Hey do you think they will go after equity release loans next!!

    Comment


      #12
      Originally posted by me206et View Post
      Hey do you think they will go after equity release loans next!!
      It's stupid comments like that one that doesn't help things.

      The 2019 tax rules are part of the current finance act published last week. Read that to find the actual details....
      merely at clientco for the entertainment

      Comment


        #13
        Originally posted by me206et View Post

        Hey do you think they will go after equity release loans next!!
        I would imagine that they will now...
        "I can put any old tat in my sig, put quotes around it and attribute to someone of whom I've heard, to make it sound true."
        - Voltaire/Benjamin Franklin/Anne Frank...

        Comment


          #14
          Originally posted by me206et View Post
          Being very naive, if the loan is paid off will it be reported to HRMC in 2019.
          Are they saying that every single loan ever made since 1999 has to be declared and if paid off, how and how much and when it was repaid?
          Is it just EBT loans contractors loans etc.?
          Close, but not quite. There are something like seven circumstances for loans when lots of stuff lots need to be reported (including name, phone number, email address, name of the scheme, NI No, UTR, whether there's been a settlement, etc) including:

          - the initial principal amount of the loan,
          - the amount that has become principal under the loan, otherwise than by capitalisation of interest, in each relevant tax year,
          - the amount of principal under the loan repaid in each relevant tax year, ignoring any repayments not in money made on or after 17 March 2016,
          - the details of any repayment that is to be disregarded (because it's not been repaid in money)
          - the amount of principal under the loan that has been released or written off in each relevant tax year,

          And a "relevant tax year" means (a) the tax year in which the loan was made, and (b) each subsequent tax year.

          One of the seven circumstances is when the loan (or quasi-loan) is still outstanding on 5 April 2019. I've not time to study it properly, but it looks like another one is where the loan was oustanding on 16 March 2016.

          Comment


            #15
            Originally posted by eek View Post
            I can see a few flaws in the initial sentence but don't know enough about the scheme in detail to know whether the flaws are real or not.

            And that is the problem with all these schemes - they are pulling tricks based on details and the devil is very much in the exact detail of the scheme and whether it was implemented exactly as described (assuming it even worked in the first place).

            That is why you need specialist advice and it is why that specialist advice is going to cost. Its also why I would recommend being very careful here as its possibly you could create a situation where you don't just have 1 tax bill to pay from the original scheme but instead end up with 2 - one for the original scheme and another one for the scheme that supposedly "fixed" the first one.

            However I will add one final warning here. Tax Schemes are games for the very wealthy to play who can spend the £100,000 in professional advice and gambling £2m in fines to avoid a £5m bill. The professional charges required to get sensible advice here are not ones anyone here will be able to pay (as Webberg stated yesterday a tax advisor will charge £400+ an hour and need a few hours before being able to give you advice) which is why you need advice on a group basis - its also why you need to make your own decisions and not listen to the advice of non-specialists - which includes, ironically, me...
            There is an accountancy firm running this new operation with the trustee, so I have paid for their 'advice', which has been chronic and largely inaccurate. As it's the accountancy firm which came up with the various proposals, there is obviously a bit of self-interest in convincing everyone with relevant loans that these proposals are water-tight and there will be no comeback. But I'm not going to pay another firm to comment on the proposals as none of them really know what's going to unfold in the next couple of years.

            Comment


              #16
              Originally posted by me206et View Post
              Being very naive, if the loan is paid off will it be reported to HRMC in 2019.
              Are they saying that every single loan ever made since 1999 has to be declared and if paid off, how and how much and when it was repaid?
              Is it just EBT loans contractors loans etc.?

              Hey do you think they will go after equity release loans next!!
              HMRC will only receive details of loans which haven't been paid off by 2019, which to me is the driver for clearing loans in closed years. Where HMRC already know about a particular year and there is an enquiry, it's unclear whether they will accept what the accountancy firm in question are saying i.e. repay the loan and the enquiry closes.

              Comment


                #17
                Originally posted by FakeHorizon View Post
                HMRC will only receive details of loans which haven't been paid off by 2019
                That's not right. If the draft legislation published today comes in then you will have to give details of loans repaid on or after 16 March 2016.

                Comment


                  #18
                  Originally posted by Iliketax View Post
                  That's not right. If the draft legislation published today comes in then you will have to give details of loans repaid on or after 16 March 2016.
                  But the trust won't supply them as a matter of course, is what I'm getting at. Although that is irrelevant if we have to provide details ourselves. Again, paid-for advice proving to be spectacularly useless and only given to convince people to pay off the loans.
                  Last edited by FakeHorizon; 13 September 2017, 19:02.

                  Comment


                    #19
                    Originally posted by FakeHorizon View Post
                    But the trust won't supply them as a matter of course, is what I'm getting at. Although that is irrelevant if we have to provide details ourselves. Again, paid-for advice proving to be spectacularly useless and only given to convince people to pay off the loans.
                    You have to supply the information to HMRC yourself. If you don't, it's a £300 penalty, which can then increase to £60 per day for not doing it. If you supply inaccurate info, there's another £3,000. HMRC will create a "digital tool" for you to supply the information.

                    To be fair to whoever you paid, this only came out yesterday morning and is still in draft.

                    HMRC has also been quite clever about this in that (i) if they know of the scheme already then they put a tick on their list of schemes, (ii) if one person reports a new scheme then they add that to the list and can try to find out who else has participated.

                    Comment


                      #20
                      Originally posted by Iliketax View Post
                      You have to supply the information to HMRC yourself. If you don't, it's a £300 penalty, which can then increase to £60 per day for not doing it. If you supply inaccurate info, there's another £3,000. HMRC will create a "digital tool" for you to supply the information.

                      To be fair to whoever you paid, this only came out yesterday morning and is still in draft.

                      HMRC has also been quite clever about this in that (i) if they know of the scheme already then they put a tick on their list of schemes, (ii) if one person reports a new scheme then they add that to the list and can try to find out who else has participated.
                      That's all very well. But how long are you supposed to keep records. I might have some info re loans in 2000/2002 but not complete figures, and not all schemes?

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X