Rangers Tax Case Supreme Court 15 & 16 March

[sbar99920]

SC case

I have watched the feed. For me the appellant put forward a very strong case. But my EBTs range from 2011-12 to 2014-15, they mention a change of legislation. When did that come into force to make all loan payments taxable?

[neetrocfp]

2019

Will the new legislation proposed for 2019 be subject to judicial review as were APN's?

[DotasScandal]

Will the new legislation proposed for 2019 be subject to judicial review as were APN's?

You'll have to wait until 2019 to know.
Cannot initiate a JR until you have been actually affected by the legislation.

[neetrocfp]

You'll have to wait until 2019 to know.
Cannot initiate a JR until you have been actually affected by the legislation.

No doubt people will be affected and those people will want a revue; let me rephrase the question: can a judicial review be disallowed?

[sbar99920]

What now

If Rangers win their appeal, does it weaken the HMRC position regarding 2019?

[webberg]

If Rangers win their appeal, does it weaken the HMRC position regarding 2019?

No - absolutely no effect.

[DotasScandal]

No doubt people will be affected and those people will want a revue; let me rephrase the question: can a judicial review be disallowed?

Don't know. But it's not enough to "want" one - it needs to be funded, and that's out of reach for most people.

[Dylan]

Don't know. But it's not enough to "want" one - it needs to be funded, and that's out of reach for most people.

Disagree, this is the one catch all piece of legislation where we can all join together as it isn't scheme specific, will be cheap as chips!

[Jes1]

Disagree, this is the one catch all piece of legislation where we can all join together as it isn't scheme specific, will be cheap as chips!

Sounds like you're talking about BIG Group which already exists, a group where everyone joins together (except those who have stuck their head in the sand) and isn't scheme specific.

[Dylan]

Sounds like you're talking about BIG Group which already exists, a group where everyone joins together (except those who have stuck their head in the sand) and isn't scheme specific.

No.

I'm not a member of BG, it doesn't give me anything at all but don't have my head in the sand.

For the 2019 JR all the groups (inc BG) can band together.